Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Cow Mothers

Cow Mothers

Dalbir · 19 Aug 2006

Out of interest, does anyone know exactly why Hindus refer to cows as "gow mata"? Is it simply down to cows giving milk or something more deeper than this? Plus someone told me that old Hindu scriptures mention their gods making animal sacrifices, is this true?

Re: Cow Mothers

aanjan · 19 Aug 2006

If gau is the mata then bull should be pita shri.......like husband of the mother will be the father. Maybe we will need to re-write evolution.

Re: Cow Mothers

Sitara · 19 Aug 2006

___ Out of interest, does anyone know exactly why Hindus refer to cows as "gow mata"? Is it simply down to cows giving milk or something more deeper than this? ___ Correct. When you are born, you drink your mother's milk - no one elses but your mothers milk. For the rest of your life, we sustain ourselves on Cows milk i.e. the very same milk the cow gives her children (her calves). Therefore the logic goes that by drinking her milk we have a "sambandh" with the cow and so she is seen as the mother. I mean does it sound right to take milk from a cow and then slaughter her when she is too old. Sounds rather cruel and ungrateful doesn't it? I am sure, as a human being, you would agree. _______ Out of interest, does anyone know exactly why Hindus refer to cows as "gow mata"? Is it simply down to cows giving milk or something more deeper than this? _______ There is mention of animal sacrafices but it is forbidden in Kal-Yug to perform this. The animals were sacrifced and with the power of mantras these living beings were rejuvinated with a new lease of life.

Re: Cow Mothers

JSGyani · 19 Aug 2006

the cow is the most common milk giivng animal in India...so imho that is the reason....its ones second mum..as we drink its milk. ( but if Cow is my mum..then if i drink goats milk..then bakree is my massi..and oothnee would be Taiyee..and majjhh would be chachee..waht about bhedd ??...) Animal sacriifce was practised by Hindus..it is emntioned in their religioous texts..hom yagg genda maar etc rhinocerous sacriifce.. BUT now NCERT is busy DISTORTING SIKH history in the books ( to give Sikhs a BAD name).. and WIPING out all such cow sacrifice stories to give a new "image" to current hidnu beleifs.. [%sig%]

Re: Cow Mothers

JSGyani · 19 Aug 2006

2. Oops left out this.. BTW if anyone has seen the way the COWS are treated in INDIA..roaming the streets eating RUBBISH..diseased and sick...any wonder that SIKHS and other minorites are treated worse.... Just imagine IF a "MOTHER" gets such sham treatment form her SONS..who are SIKHS ..to cry ?? 3. INDIA is the bIGGEST exporter of Cow HIDE !! and Most Malaysain Imported BEEF is also from INDIA... [%sig%]

Re: Cow Mothers

Dalbir · 19 Aug 2006

What if you are allergic to cows milk? Like some people are, and you drink goats milk instead? Does that make it Bakri mata ----------------------- Sitara you said: When you are born, you drink your mother's milk - no one elses but your mothers milk. For the rest of your life, we sustain ourselves on Cows milk i.e. the very same milk the cow gives her children (her calves). Therefore the logic goes that by drinking her milk we have a "sambandh" with the cow and so she is seen as the mother. Most of the world drinks cow milk this way, how comes no one else had the idea to call cows their mothers?

Re: Cow Mothers

aanjan · 20 Aug 2006

If cow is the mum then the bull should be Pita Shri?

Re: Cow Mothers

kds1980 · 20 Aug 2006

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Correct. When you are born, you drink your mother's milk - no one elses but your mothers milk. For the rest of your life, we sustain ourselves on Cows milk i.e. the very same milk the cow gives her children (her calves). Therefore the logic goes that by drinking her milk we have a "sambandh" with the cow and so she is seen as the mother. I mean does it sound right to take milk from a cow and then slaughter her when she is too old. Sounds rather cruel and ungrateful doesn't it? I am sure, as a human being, you would agree. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ sitara ji over 50% of milk in india is produced by buffaloes.but there is no ban on buffaloe slaughter.no hindu give respect of mother to the buffaloes even in some places buffaloe calves are sacrificed to please goddess durga because she killed mahishahsura( a buffaloe headed asura).by your logic hindus should also give equal respect to buffaloes.may i ask you why there is such a discrimination with buffaloes?

Re: Cow Mothers

Sitara · 20 Aug 2006

_______________ but if Cow is my mum..then if i drink goats milk..then bakree is my massi..and oothnee would be Taiyee..and majjhh would be chachee..waht about bhedd ??...) _______________ Sometimes with the stuff you come out with, I can't help but believe this is true...only joking Paaji!! It seems no matter what Hindus do with good intention (i.e. show respect for a Cow etc), Sikhs like you will always come and find faults and have a good old p**s take. Ah well there is no pleasing some people. _______________ BUT now NCERT is busy DISTORTING SIKH history in the books ( to give Sikhs a BAD name).. and WIPING out all such cow sacrifice stories to give a new "image" to current hidnu beleifs.. _______________ You sound very paranoid my freind...chill out. NCERT is a communist-backed organisation, they are also distorting Hindu history - even more than Sikh history...Poor Sikhs, it always about the Sikhs isn't it. The way some people talk on here, you would think that the GoI's sole agenda is to wipe out Sikhs...forget things like Aids, poverty etc etc... __________ BTW if anyone has seen the way the COWS are treated in INDIA..roaming the streets eating RUBBISH..diseased and sick...any wonder that SIKHS and other minorites are treated worse.... Just imagine IF a "MOTHER" gets such sham treatment form her SONS..who are SIKHS ..to cry ?? 3. INDIA is the bIGGEST exporter of Cow HIDE !! and Most Malaysain Imported BEEF is also from INDIA... ____________ This is why India is in such a cr@py state at the moment. The people have forgoten there Dharam and become the most selfish and ungrateful bunch of idiots. BTW its not just Sikhs that are treated badly..you think the average Hindu has got it good??? The average Sikhs lives much better than the average Hindu. The average Sikhs doesn't have to worry about if he/she will get a meal the next day, so get off your high horse. [%sig%]

Re: Cow Mothers

Sardar · 20 Aug 2006

[b]Sitara wrote: > ___ > Out of interest, does anyone know exactly why Hindus refer to > cows as "gow mata"? > > Is it simply down to cows giving milk or something more deeper > than this? > ___ > > Correct. When you are born, you drink your mother's milk - no > one elses but your mothers milk. For the rest of your life, we > sustain ourselves on Cows milk i.e. the very same milk the cow > gives her children (her calves). Therefore the logic goes that > by drinking her milk we have a "sambandh" with the cow and so > she is seen as the mother. > > I mean does it sound right to take milk from a cow and then > slaughter her when she is too old. Sounds rather cruel and > ungrateful doesn't it? I am sure, as a human being, you would > agree. > > _______ > Out of interest, does anyone know exactly why Hindus refer to > cows as "gow mata"? > > Is it simply down to cows giving milk or something more deeper > than this? > _______ > > There is mention of animal sacrafices but it is forbidden in > Kal-Yug to perform this. The animals were sacrifced and with > the power of mantras these living beings were rejuvinated with > a new lease of life.[/b] How is someone who is going through 8.4 million life forms be your mother? [%sig%]

Re: Cow Mothers

JSGyani · 21 Aug 2006

There is mention of animal sacrafices but it is forbidden in Kal-Yug to perform this. The animals were sacrifced and with the power of mantras these living beings were rejuvinated with a new lease of life. ??????????????? whay "KILL" ( end life ) and then use mantras to REVIVE ?? Or was the cow killed say wehn too old to walk..and REJUVENATED as a NEW BORN CALF ?? that would be acceptable to me....get new born calf out of an old hag about to die..Mantra or no mantara...and since a New Born Calf needs a MOTHER..how does that part of this equation work out ?? ( remember there is only ONE animal..being killed and then revived !!)..or does the Mantra also provide MILK !! fantastic. maybe the Mantra was CLONING MANTRA..long forgotten and now revived by Western Scinetists..in KAL YUGG !!! 2. People can so readily beleive in such "mantras"....and find it hard to beleive in Vasakhi 1699 ?? Couldnt Guru Gobind Singh ji "rejuvenate"...or is that impossible because it was already KALYUGG..and so such mantras are banned ??? funny isnt it. [%sig%]

Re: Cow Mothers

Sitara · 22 Aug 2006

___________________ What if you are allergic to cows milk? Like some people are, and you drink goats milk instead? Does that make it bakri mata ____________________ If someone is allergic to cows milk then there are more chances that they will be allergic to goats milk. But anyway going by my logic, you are correct. In fact we should view all animals as our family but cow is given special importance since in ancient times people relied on cows to produce milk and used the dung for fuel and similarly the bull was used to toil the field and so he was referred to as a father. _____________ Most of the world drinks cow milk this way, how comes no one else had the idea to call cows their mothers? __________ I don’t know. You asked a question on why Hindus revere the cow and to be honest, I did my best to answer your question based on my limited knowledge. I hope you can appreciate that. [%sig%]

Re: Cow Mothers

Dalbir · 22 Aug 2006

I appreciate it. But it does seem ridiculous to call your mum a cow, must have been a complete moron who thought that one up.

Re: Cow Mothers

JSGyani · 23 Aug 2006

Most of the world drinks cow milk this way, how comes no one else had the idea to call cows their mothers? ????????????? No body can answer this..not even Sitara Ji. After all the whole world has peopel working at different occupations..blacksmiths, scavengers, wood carvers, idol makers, buisnessmen, priests...etc etc..BUT only Hindus categorised them into 4 Castes based on their occupation..no one else thought of this.. Women are widowed all over the world...only in India they are SATEE..burned alive !!! Many many other mysteries.. SO what happens in different cultures or why..is anybody's guess.. [%sig%]

Re: Cow Mothers

Sitara · 24 Aug 2006

<> What a thought provoking and intelligent response. You guys continue to astound me with your wit and intelligence. But anyway lets go along with your logic. Surely the person who discovered cows milk was an even bigger moron? I mean either that person was so convinced that the cow was their mother that they went far enough to drink the cows milk or maybe they were perverted but either way they are are moron right? But even bigger morons are the ones who followed - and continue to follow to this day - that moron who discovered cows milk. That means I am a moron and you are probably a moron (assuming you consume cows milk)...think about it my friend! [%sig%]

Re: Cow Mothers

Dalbir · 25 Aug 2006

But anyway lets go along with your logic. Surely the person who discovered cows milk was an even bigger moron? I mean either that person was so convinced that the cow was their mother that they went far enough to drink the cows milk or maybe they were perverted but either way they are are moron right? But even bigger morons are the ones who followed - and continue to follow to this day - that moron who discovered cows milk. That means I am a moron and you are probably a moron (assuming you consume cows milk)...think about it my friend! ------------------------------------------------------ Man does not live off cows milk alone! Early people probably went for whatever they could get their hands on to survive. There is a big difference difference between having cows milk in your diet and conceptualising a cow as a mother figure because of this. Anyway, enough of this, I got the info I required, i.e. cow mother conceptualisation is baseless and pointless. But everyone is free to do whatever floats their boat.....

Re: Cow Mothers

Sitara · 27 Aug 2006

Dalbir, Fair enough paaji. I hope you have learnt something from your initial question. No hard feelings on my part (even though you tried to insult my culture calling the person who came up with the 'cow mother' concept a moron). Take care

Re: Cow Mothers

Sitara · 27 Aug 2006

Dalbir, Fair enough paaji. I honestly hope you have learnt something from your initial question. No hard feelings on my part (even though you tried to insult my culture calling the person who came up with the 'cow mother' concept a moron). Take care

Re: Cow Mothers

Dalbir · 27 Aug 2006

Author: Sitara Date: 08-27-06 05:45 Dalbir, Fair enough paaji. I honestly hope you have learnt something from your initial question. No hard feelings on my part (even though you tried to insult my culture calling the person who came up with the 'cow mother' concept a moron). Take care ------------------------------------------- No hard feelings Sitara, even though some of your people are trying to interfere with everything my people do or aspire to. Take care yourself

Re: Cow Mothers

Dalbir · 29 Aug 2006

Of all the problems in the world, basing a religion with a strong focus on cow adoration seems a bit...........i dunno...........offpoint.... Why not focus on environment, social justice for unfortunates or something noble like that...... Throwing Hari Singh Nalwas actions in our face as if to justify cow deification is pointless, most Sikhs agree the raj was a time when Sikhism was heavily influenced by outside Hindu forces. You just provide information to validate that point. I mean you would be on stronger ground if you said all animals were equally deserving of care, instead of singling out a particular one as if it were worth more than the others. Plus you need to explain why Hindus without precendent became vegetarians when their scriptures contain references to animal sacrifices. I recently met an English guy who spent time in the Hilly areas in HP, he told me he witnessed a Hindu ceremony where more than 20 different types of animals were sacrificed. This was within the last few years.

Re: Cow Mothers

Ek_singh · 03 Sep 2006

You can get details here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacred_cow

Re: Cow Mothers

Ek_singh · 03 Sep 2006

Bull is also sacred as per relgious thinking for some.. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bull_worship

Re: Cow Mothers

livingforwaheguru · 03 Sep 2006

I just want to say something to sitara. Through this thread i have developed immense amount of respect for you. You have taken the abuse of your culture and beliefs with such grace and diginity. If some narrow minded person belittled my faith as some people have done to your beliefs. I would not be so calm and my krodh would come out. So I applaud you on your efforts to keep it civil and your control of krodh, even though you are being barmbarded with insensitive, unforgivable remarks. It saddens me that so called "giannis" and "sikhs" from my faith have so much hatred for others who are the same as them because of there humanity. It saddens me that instead of discussing ones beliefs in a positive and non ridiculing manner we try to belittle others to make ourselves feel supreme. Sikhs, We have a faith that is based on love and tolerance. Just because certain people in a faith are trying to mess with our history, that doesn't give us the right to ridicule the entire faith and hurt the hearts of our fellow human family. Hurting someones feelings is in my opinion one of the worst paaps we can do. If you don't agree with something then state it in a civilized and appropiate manner. Just like you would want someone who doesn't agree with our faith to do. On of my best friends is a hindu and he is one of the most spiritual ppl i know. And i have hung out with a few amritdharis who do kirtan at the gurdwara. And i have to say from my own experience that there jeevan doesn't match what they sing on stage. And then i have this hindu brother who loves my faith and encourages me to practice it and believe in it and do it with all my heart. So please do not ridicule his faith. Waheguru ANG SANG

Re: Cow Mothers

Sitara · 04 Sep 2006

livingforwaheguru, You think too highly of me my friend. I am also at fault for coming under Krodh (and I apologise for offending any of my Sikh Veers/Bhains as a result). I always try to be the 'better man' and in Kal-yug it is very difficult, you will always get people taking this to be a sign of weakness and they proceed to spit in your face but we Hindus are used to it... we get from all sides - Muslims, Christians, Rationalists and now Sikhs. I know that in their hearts, Sikhs like Dalbir do not really feel hatred for Hindus he/she is just a little misguided and I sometimes try to look over some of the hurtful and harsh comments they make but sometimes i can't help but to respond. Anyway take care Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Cow Mothers

JSGyani · 04 Sep 2006

Dear livingforwaheguur jio, to each his own set of experiences... I not only have "friends" who are hindus..i also have "relatives"...who are hindus...Every Gurpurab of Guur nanak Ji..I visited so many HINDU MERCHANTS..who not only gave generously for the Gurpurab Celebrations at the Gurdwara...but also NEVER let our party go off without lots of Barfee and Laddoos.. many SIKHS also "avoided" us....???? pretended they were rushing off to a very important buisnss meetings and so on... Guur Ji also had a hindu friend..named Gangu....and also Nabi Khan, Ghani Khan.... doesnt mean ALL hindus are Ganggu..and ALL Muslims are Nabhi Khan or Pir Budhu Shahs I have dealt with lots of Amrtidharees..who also sing gurbani..so far I have no complaints...maybe you mixed with the wrong "Amrtidharees"... I have also visited the local mandir to help out in some functions..i sit on the local shamshan bhomee committe which includes the mandirs and gurdwaras... Just like Sitara is cool and calm..so are many "gianis" and "sikhs" cool and calm..and i am sure we are ALL for WAHEGURU ( none for satan) WAHEGURU AANG SAANG JI. [%sig%]

Re: Cow Mothers

Dalbiri · 04 Sep 2006

Living for Waheguru - It was very touching to hear about your close relationship with your Hindu friend....... Sitara I came on this site to learn from practising Sikhs and dialog with them, why do I have to hear Hindu propaganda from the likes of you? Do you plan to convert to Sikhism, or else why are you here? To push the Hindu point of view? What's the agenda? LivingForWaheguru, you say "Just because certain people in a faith are trying to mess with our history, that doesn't give us the right to ridicule the entire faith and hurt the hearts of our fellow human family." .....err are you nuts? Don't you know that thousands of Sikhs have been killed with the government go-ahead in India? Why are you not acknowledging this? Why are you playing down the genocide of Sikhs? Are you sure you are Sikh? And Sitara you are right, I have absolutely no "hate" for Hindus. I am, however, no fan of what seems to me to be a corrupt heartless ideology that strives to strangle all others around them in their embrace. PS - Had to make new login for a reason that is too boring and long to get into.

Re: Cow Mothers

livingforwaheguru · 04 Sep 2006

JS ARSHI GIANNI. I think you misunderstood me brother. I did not mean to make it sound like amritdharis are bad. What i meant to say is that i have met a few bad apple from the amritdhari pool...although i have met some amazing jeevani walle sikhs. Bhai jeevan singh ji, sant maskeen ji, bhai jasbir singh ji i am particularly close with. But in my day to day lives i have also met some great amazing gursikhs who have inspired me beyone measure. BUT... what i'm saying is you can't judge an entire religion by the few bad apples. Just like i obviously don't judge all amritdharis by the few i encountered who don't have the best jeevani. So shouldn't u codemn an entire nation of people by the bad apples. I do agree there is a serious problem with RSS and all those fundamental hindus. DALBIRI am I nuts? No. Playing down the genocide of the sikhs? Wow i think you must be high brother cause the genocide of the sikhs has never even come into this conversation. So you wanna assume i would play down the genocide of the sikhs i'm gonna assume you are hate filled paranoid person. Is that fair. As for your question of am i a sikh? Umm well i have been amritshaked for four years taking amrit from taksali singhs. However i consider myself a sikh of the entire human race not a particular jatha. I probably think this cause i know i'm not pure enough to be a part of taksal or akj. I have the utmost respect for all jathas especially the previously mentioned two. My hero is sant...get this...Jarnail singh Ji Khalsa bhindernwale. Ever heard of him? Oh and i got interested in him through this person i met in india who talked so highly of him. THE WEIRD THING WAS HE WAS A HINDU from punjab. But i guess i should have killed him right dilbiri? I mean he must be a fanatic cause hes a hindu... The essence of hinduism is love and the belief in one supreme universal being. ANd self introspesctive meditation. Not the fundemental beliefs RSS spew. Listen you have tested my last nerves diribi. whatever ur name is. I know how much the genocide has effected me and my life and what i have done because of it. I don't need to tell you. I don't even know why i'm bothering posting and arguing with you, its a waste of time..But oh well i guess it the ego in me. Please don't ever question my faith. It hurts me when you do so. But something tells me you really don't care if you hurt the sentiments of other fellow human brothers. I guess i should have more pyaar for you, cause you seem to have so much hatred for others. Only pyaar can overcome that. Please i hope one day you get to the level where u realize at the end of the day we are one entire human race. And i'm not condoning sitting back and letting hindus or muslims or martians opress us. I'm saying no mattter what, we have to see the beauty in all races. We are against evil actions not any human person. A true gursikhs enemy is evil deeds not any human being or race. I hope you understand that. And if you don't then honestly brother i feel sorry for you. Regardless of what the mughals did the gurus still had muslim gurmukh pyaray who loved the gurus and who they loved. And get this it was the same with the hill rajas. Whatever they did the gurus still had hindus who were close to them. Why don't you consult your Guru and ask him what he thinks of the hindus and muslims that have there writings included in our Guru ji. Look I don't want an argument on here if u got anymore questions or thoughts about my sikhi email me. I will sort it all out with you there.

Re: Cow Mothers

Sitara · 05 Sep 2006

<> On this thread you asked why Hindus revere the cow as a mother and as a HINDU I tried to give an explanation. I feel I was respectfull even though I could detect a contemptuous tone in your post. I feel I was honest and sincere in my answer but yet you felt to further ridicule my belief and culture by calling the person who invented the concept a moron. Do you have any idea how this makes you (and Sikhs) look? If by doing this you feel more stronger in your Sikhi/Jeevan (i.e. by dissing Hinduism to make you feel better about your Sikh religion) then I am glad I could be of assitance. In answer to your last part of your statement, I have always said that Sikhi and Hindu dharam are separate and the sooner we recognise this the better for all concerned. This always seems to be the root cause of conflicts between Sikhs and us. But we always loose whatever we do. Sikhs are always complaining about how ungrateful we are to the sacrafices and Shaheedi the Gurus made and when we [Hindus] do our best to show our appreciation, we are accused of trying to absorb Sikhi. On the other hand if we ignore this then we are accused of being ungrateful pompous bahmans...we are damned if we do and damned if we don't! <> I thought as much but like I said I think you are a little misguided. Perhaps with time you will broaden your mind and not believe everthing you hear in the Gurudwara about Hindu Dharam. Anyway I think we should just agree to disagree. It doesn't seem that we will ever see eye-to-eye. God bless you my friend and I hope you can stay happy. Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Cow Mothers

Dalbiri · 05 Sep 2006

LFW, I think you've put on some serious rose tinted glasses on your view of Hindu belief, but I repect what you said, i'll get back to you via email as you suggested. Sitara, I don't think you understand my point fully. It's not Hindu's that I find a negative force but rather Hindusim, the belief system. It's some of the ideas behind the system that I am no fan of. The parts that make it akin to aparteid and those that attempt to assimilate/absorb others. I'm also no fan of blind belief to rituals without a clear reason, hence my questions about cow worship. I will put my hands up to perhaps being a bit haughty, but in this climate, it's hard not to feel Sikhs are under attack from various sources and get hawkish. You said regarding Sikh and Hindu independence: This always seems to be the root cause of conflicts between Sikhs and us. But we always loose whatever we do. Sikhs are always complaining about how ungrateful we are to the sacrafices and Shaheedi the Gurus made and when we [Hindus] do our best to show our appreciation, we are accused of trying to absorb Sikhi. On the other hand if we ignore this then we are accused of being ungrateful pompous bahmans...we are damned if we do and damned if we don't----------------------- I understand this point of yours too, I just can't see Hinduism willingly giving Sikhs the space to grow as many would like to see, i.e. true self government. Hindu's will fight this desire tooth and nail with all sorts of underhand moves. And please don't suggest that I am critical of other systems just to feel better about my own. I am capable of seeing the truths about my own people even when this is not pleasant, I'm not prone to idealise them as some are suggesting.

Re: Cow Mothers

Balbir Singh · 05 Sep 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! I, nowhere in scriptures, found 'the cow is holy'. Cows serve people in many ways. Their urine is used in some ayurvedic medicines. Dung is used to keep huts hygienically safe. People also burn it to win energy for cooking. The cow's hide is used to make shoes etc. Their milk and milk products are necessity and liked by many. It seems that cows are serving human beings in many ways since ages. People wished and prayed their presence for a family since ancient times. Mothers wish too, to serve their children with all they have, even after death. It seems that God does not fulfill their wishes always. The cow's purposes, in my view, seem to get fulfilled by serving human beings even after death becoming food for some. Perhaps this was the reason that cows got respect in the world knowingly or unknowingly. I know that cows are not giving birth to human beings but we may ask any good mother. She may love to serve her children like a dedicated animal, preferably a cow. Apart from this, Gurus have not asked Sikhs to hate cows nor they have instructed Sikhs to hate cow lovers. Balbir Singh

Re: Cow Mothers

Dalbiri · 08 Sep 2006

I heard that there is also a sakhi in Parchian seva das where a person came crying to Guru Gobind Singh Ji's darbar, saying that he had sinned by accidently slaughtering a cow but Guru ji said basically he had not sinned and this accident was common place. Can anyone verify this? Apparently IOSS published a translation of parchian seva das, has anyone got it to check?

Re: Cow Mothers

Dalbiri · 09 Sep 2006

So as per you Sikhism is following the Darwinian procress of evolution i.e. it was less evolved in the begining when Gurus were present and reaching towards higher purity with the advent of Khalistanis right?. -------------------------------- What has this to do with anything? I don't understand what you mean, please elaborate if you want. Can you explain me how keeping "Kesh" pleases Akal ?. But you as Sikh needs no explanation because it is in your conciousness. Same is true here about Cow. Cow alone is worshipped because as per Hindu BELIEFS all the Gods are present in the cow. ---------------------------------------- No not all all. It was Guru Gobind Singh Ji's way of making Sikhs distinguished from others as a result of no one coming forward openly when Guru Tegh Bahadur was executed. It is part of the Khalsa soldiers uniform so one cannot deny his/her faith. SO HINDUS NEED NOT EXPLAIN ANYONE WHY THEY WORSHIP COWS?. THEY WILL WORHIP WHAT EVER THEY LIKE. IT IS THEIR CHOICE. ------------------------------------------------------------ No one is saying otherwise. I don't care what people worship as long as it doesn't interfere with me beit phallic symbols, deities, the sun, the moon, cows, goats, elephants, monkeys....I don't care

Re: Cow Mothers

Balbir Singh · 10 Sep 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Chandra Singh Ji! Quote "SARVE DEVAAH STHITA DEHE SARVA DEVAMAYEEHI GAOU" Please provide the reference where in Scriptures they write this and on which page. I will be thankful. Quote "The above shloka means that all the deities dwell in the body of a cow. Therefore the cow itself is as holier, as the deities." I always wanted to know why many have become cow worshipers. I hope I have understood your pleading correctly. Those who wanted to please all Devas at one stroke, they started worshiping a cow. I read that all the Devas are also in human beings. May I ask why some prefer cows than human beings? Quote "SO HINDUS NEED NOT EXPLAIN ANYONE WHY THEY WORSHIP COWS?. THEY WILL WORHIP WHAT EVER THEY LIKE. IT IS THEIR CHOICE." It is perfectly all right. All Devas, also in a cow, serve God's Will. I hope people do not mind when true Sikhs get directly connected with God and execute HIS Will. Balbir Singh