Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

Ibin Sikh · 18 Aug 2006

On another forum someone mentioned that there is an AKJ group in Canada who are followers of "Amabala Sahib" and that they dont beleive in Dasam Granth Bani. I live in Canada and have never heard of this group of AKJ. Does anyone have any idea if such a group even exists or is this all just made up to make AKJ look bad?

Re: Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

Ibin Sikh · 21 Aug 2006

But Vijaydeep Singh, on another forum you claimed that there are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib, and these AKJ followers are from Canada. I am from Canada, and honestly I have never heard of this group of AKJ that you speak of. Perhaps you can shed some light on who these AKJ followers are.

Re: Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

The Khalsa Fauj · 22 Aug 2006

Well, he is probably reffering to Prof. Uday Singh. Vijaydeep, I haven't read Harbans Singh's book but he is a shady guy though. Since you have read his book, why didn't you answer my Qs that day?? I need valid answers and I will agree with you. Also, Giani Bhag Singh Ambala didn't reject all of Dasam Granth as not bani.

Re: Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

Ibin Sikh · 23 Aug 2006

Oh… so now I get it. I thought Amabala Sahib was some dera. I never knew you guys were talking about a guy named Ambala.

Re: Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

Seeker of the Truth · 24 Aug 2006

Sikh is a Sikh! There's no such thing as an AKJ Sikh. You people need to stop following these groups. Now I understand why a lot of people are confused about the Sikh faith. [%sig%]

Re: Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

The Khalsa Fauj · 25 Aug 2006

Vijaydeep, your answer to why Peer Buddu Shah is not mentioned in bachitter natak is not very convincing at all. It is not hard to make up stories to prove yourself right. Whenever, there is war. There are going to be deaths and Peer Ji's son and brother became Shaheeds. They were not just casualties. It does not make sence to not include them and yet mention Kirpal Dass Udasi. Your translation of Ajan Bah is also incorrect. It means methods of birth/creation are in Your hands. You still have not answered how Mohammed came after Gorakh Nath and Ramanand???? Was the Shaheedi of Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji for all of humanity and for freedom of religion or was it to tilak and janju only???? Mur Pit Poorabh Keeyas Pyaana! Bhaant Bhaant Kay Teerath Naana! Jub Hee Jaat Tirbhanee Bha-aye! Pun Daan Din Kurrrt Bittaa-aye! Tahe Parkaas Hamara Bhaeoo! Patnaa Sahar Bikhay Bhuv Laeoo! Where in Gurmat does it state to go on bathing at hindu pilgrimages??? Where does it say to give donations to brahmans???? That Shabad is not related to what we are talking about at all. That Shabad means Akaal is everywhere and prevails hrough all. I came across a tukh presented by your fellows yesterday. The tukh was Goapi Nai Goalieyaa! See the proper way to understand it on www.sikhsangat.com in the general topic. Tell me one place where Guru Ji attached numbers to appearence of Akaal?? Guru Ji used # for only 1 purpose which is to promote that God is one. Guru Ji used # 1 to promote the concept of 1 God. Then how does the concept of 4 arms come into play??? When bachitter natak says mahakal drinks liqor and then roars. What Gurmat is that promoting?? No wonder 90% of so called male Sikhs drink. The God described in Natak is exactly the same thing as Shiv. There is no difference. Same 4 arms, garland of dead, druggie, jhaanjraa, ghungroos, red toungue sticking out, scary looking jaw, has conches and daouroo, sounds scary that even kings get scared and run away, says that you are drunk and hold a sword in the hand, laughs like haahaa hoohoo, blood drips from the mala of heads, scary sounding ghunts alaso sound. How does God remain Akaal if this is the desription????? Gurbani says Mitth Bolraa Jee Hur Sajjan Swami Mora Hao Summal THukee Jee Oh Kday Naa Bolai kauraa and not scary sounding evil maniac. What kindof joke is this?? This is just making fun of Akaal. This is why Gurbani says: Logan Raam Khilona Jaana. That is what the writer of bachitter natak has made it out to be. Also why is there need for Guru Ji to mention past life?? If Guru Anagad Ji and other Guru don't even mention present life then why was there need for 10th Paatshah to mention past life at a place no one knows. How long are our Sikhs going to continue to act like uneducated fools?? When will they realize the chaals of brahmans??? I didn't even touch on the part of vishnu saying he will come back as Nanak in Kalyug.

Re: Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

The Khalsa Fauj · 28 Aug 2006

I am not 40. Not even close. 21. Vijaydepp, I don't know if you do it on purpose or not but your writing style is confusing and sometimes hard to understand what you are saying. As for aarths of that Mur Pit Poorabh Keeyas Pyaana. All you are doing again is making things up without proof. What special pun daan was done at tribeni which wasn't done at other places??? You can never explain why God is given characteristics of shiv. Also, you do aarth based on hindu mythology. You don't do aarth based on Tat Gurmat. You have to relate everything to purans and vedas. Why?? Rss agenda?? You also called Purans holy. Why?? RSS agenda??? Guru Ji would not use misleading words. As for the Peer Buddhu Shah thing, I don't know what you are talking about. What you are saying is misleading and confusing. How was Kirpal Kutkoo greater than peer Buddhu Shah??? Since he lost loved ones, he deserved more respect. Why are you relating this to what happened between Muslim writers and hindu writers????? Khalsa is Niyara.

Re: Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

The Khalsa Fauj · 30 Aug 2006

Why do you not write clearly when it comes to Peer Buddhu Shah?? What are you trying to say??? You being part of indian military also shows you are a supporter of Indian govt. Thus you say no to Khalistan so you are not Khalsa. I don't like indian govt. people. It was people like you who attacked Darbar Sahib. As for you using tukhs from Guru Granth Sahib Ji, they in no way can be used to prove that Guru Ji is taking about giving Naam Daan. The fact is that it is not naam daan but daan to brahmans due to Tribeni. As for Nahana. There is only 1 aarth. My mistake for repeatedly saying nana. It is not nana. It is nahana in dasam granth. I mistakenly missed the hahha in paiirre. Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji wrote Gurbani too and they didn't mention any nahana or trebani teerath jaana. As for the stannza. Now you are changing that too to suite you?? It was, is and will always be: Jub Lug Khala Rhay Niaraa, Tub Lugg Taij Deo Mai Saara! Jub Eh Ghai Bipran Kee Reet, Mai Naa karo In Kee Parteet! As for quoting purans and your other hindu books, that is to expose the filth brahman has created and what kind of joke it is. It mentions names of yudh participants such as Kirpal Dass, Mahree chund, Gunga Raam, Lal Chund, Daya Raam Brahman, Divaan Nund Chund, etc. but no mention of Peer Buddhu Shah. Gurmat also doesn't care about Narak or Suraj yet it says, when Sango Shah died, he went to surag. Not to forget the talk about this world going crazy and surag loak going jai jai kaar. Your analysis about Gorakh are nothing but laughable so I won't even comment. I am not even going to go over a lot of other things becuase you are here to promote dasam granth and not learn the truth about it. You will never agree because that is your order by your heads.

Re: Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

The Khalsa Fauj · 02 Sep 2006

You are a firm beliver of vedas and purans and other hindu books. Your way of interpreting Gurbani is different. The Shabads you use to backyourself are not even related to the topic, according to me. Show me one place in Guru Granth Sahib ji where bhagauti, mahakaal, or kaal are used for God. All I see you doing is promoting rss agenda and the responses you give aren't convincing at all. If you want to be Khalsa, you need to be shudh. Remember the number 1 at start of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Also, what you use is copy paste from websites. The aarths on websites aren't the best ones. Also, research and find the Shabads where narak and swarag are rejected. I don't have time to find the page # then find it on a website. According to you, God is in everything so everythiing is good. Since everything is good, there is no need for rehat. God is also in koke so start practicing it. Instead of understanding the deeper meaning you are using it to promote all of dasam granth. The shabd you gave for the response to # 4, it doesn't even include 4. So you are just trying to fool others. See the thing with me is, the more clever tactics you use, the more stronger i become in my belief. Just like: Mannu Saddee Daatree Asee Manuu Day Soaye Jeo Jeo Saanu Vudh Daa Asse Doon Swaye Hoaye As for you, I don't even consider you Sikh and Panth doesn't need bramhanvadee Sikhs either. Ever since Dasam Granth has come on the scene, has anything great happened for the Panth??? It has been on the downfall. Historical research by Punjabi University says, there was no evidence of Dasam Granth in punjab before 1806. Has the Panth been in Chardi kala since then??? Khalsa raaj got lost. Kirpan was lost, full hinduvaad came into Gurudwaras. Sikhs have become devi followers, hair cutting is to the max, hig moral character is reduced to gdaarees, posat, afeem, bhung and sura has ruined the kaum. Even Bhai Kaan Singh didn't belive in natak. Do you know more than him???? Even he said that there has to be action taken to clean up dasam granth from anti-Sikh elments. 1973, Akaal Takht issued statement that Tria Chariter isn't Gurbani. Are you above Panth now??? As for having veechaar with you, a person like you will never change and will go to any low extent to prove what he is there to prove. If you really want to talk, have a one on one live conversation and not post replies after 2 days after using the search and find tools. Also, in order to understand Gurbani, you can't just take it literally. Guru Ji has used words like narak and swarag, parjaat, etc. but in other places they have been rejected. Same for dharamraaj and jums. All these have been rejected in Gurbani. I say you listen to these audio files. To tell you the truth, I didn't even go through all the quotes you entered. Because 90% of them are usually not related to the topic. That is why I told you last time to talk screen to screen. However, you just like to post on forums like here and bombard with quotes which aren't related and aarths have not been done properly. As for Naana, if you look at the one on dasamgranth.org, it has nahana with haaha in foot. It is not hard to take the haaha out. Also what is up with the fear of running out of paper??? Guru Ji had fear of running out of paper??? The toungue is red like fire, jaws are scary. As for your quotes such as those which say that God is everywhere and is in everything doesn't make that everything is Gurmat. God made both good and bad. We take the god side. Therefore, Guru Ji would never link God as shrabee and stuff. Howver, like I said. You are free and on a mission. When time comes with Akaal kirpaa, I will come to india and we can talk in person. I don't have time to answer evey quote you put out there because it is easy to copy and paste but take time to explain. Vijaydeep, you replies are full of ideas and maybes but not facts. You also have no clue what swarag is and what narak is according to Gurbani. So the swarag natak is sending to is not as per Gurmat. I will link you to some files: http://sikhbulletin.com/audio.php Listen to them and be clear on narak and swarag. You guys can try your best to promote dasam granth as dasam Guru Granth Sahib but it won't be succesful as in the end: Koorh Nikhuttay Naankaa Orak Such Rahee! Also, don't expect me to continue this here. I have university starting and also need to work. I don't get paid by some organization to post on forums. As for joining military. Who are you to tell me what to do and what not to do??? I will do what Akaal wants me to do. I don't need to listen to a person who is stuck between 2 religions.

Re: Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

The Khalsa Fauj · 02 Sep 2006

Did you not have even a little bit of shame when you said "lughing at Japu Ji Sahib"?? Didn't your mind burn when you came up with this thought just to promote your agenda??? Those who still think this guy cares for or loves Khalsa Panth, give me a break. Gorakh was founder of his mutt which do mundraa and stuff. It even says in natak that it is Gorakh the one who put mundraa in 2 ears. Then it says that Ramanand came and started his path of bairag (bairagi mutt). Then came Mohammed according to it. Who is lying?? The write of natak or the whole world which says Mohammed came in 7th century and that Mohammed's religion was even established in India whenGorakh and Ramanand came. Koee Sharam Dharam Hai??? Such naal turrnnn dee himmat hai??? After that it goes straight to dusht daman that u have to go and do panth parchar. What were the previous 9 forms of Guru Nanakk JI Maharraj doing??? Koee Sharam Dharam Hai??? Such naal turrnnn dee himmat hai??? It is not talking about Vishnu. Vishu was already talked about at start. As for narak surag: Gurbani says: Kavan narak, Kia Surag Beechaara, santan Douuu Raaday! Hum Kaahoo Kee Kaan Na Kudtay Upnay Gurpursaaday! ----- 969 If you don't know why Guru Ji used the words narak and surag at other paces, I say go give your buddy Principal Surjit Singh a visit. Once again, if you look at some copies of dsam granth, it is nahana with haaha in the foot. Naana doesn't make sence. It also says: Pund Raj Jeh Joag Kmaava. What was so special about the punds??? Boon that first 3 Guru will be Vaidess and the it will be soadees is also false. Guru Amardaas Ji wasn't vedi, if you ever read Gurbani. Guru Nanak Ji can never be avtar of vishnu. Vishnu had issues as per Gurbani and Guru Ji doesn't say he is avtaar of vishnu. As for Bhutts swayas, they don't apply here as it is not what Guru Ji said. What bhutts said was linking Guru Ji to whatever the locals belived was great. It only says when Guru Arjun went to Prabh Loak (God's world), Guru Har Gobind became the succesor. No mention that SatGuru Ji gave Shaheedi. Not even a little mention. Then it says Ab Mai Upnee Katha Bakhano. Wasn't Guru Gobind Singh Ji joat of Guru Nanak??? Guru was Guru Nanak and not the physical bodies of succesor paatshahis. Therefore, there is no reason to say my katha bakhano. Great way to divide first 9 paatshahis from 10th paatshahi. If we read John Malcolm, he says so far, Sikhs have one holy granth but soon they will have 2. Thus, we got 2. Now got more coming up from unknown places. Sarbloh, Ugardanti, etc. etc. Who knows what else is going to come up. Then it says that Sun, Moon, Earth, Fire, etc. said to worship them. Who has proof of Sun or Moon or Fire asking to worship them??? Uklmund bunday la-ee taa ik hee ishaaraa kaafee houndaa hai purr jis taa dimaag kumm nahee kurdaa jaa kissay la-ee kumm kurdaa taaa fir kee keeta jaa sukdaaa????? I got all that anti-Gurmat stuff from 2-3 pages of bachitter natak. Forget about going to other things and writing a book. Sharam Dharam Doaye Shup Khloaye Koorh Firray Pardhaan Vay Laalo! But in the end: Koorh Nikhuttay Naankaa, Orak Such Rahee!

Re: Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

Prabhjoyt Singh · 04 Sep 2006

"ਕਹੂੰ ਸਸਤ੍ਰਧਾਰੀ ਕਹੂੰ ਬਿਦਿਆ ਕੇ ਬਿਚਾਰੀ ਕਹੂੰ ਮਾਰਤ ਅਹਾਰੀ ਕਹੂੰ ਨਾਰ ਕੇ ਨਿਕੇਤ ਹੋ ॥ कहूं ससत्रधारी कहूं बिदिआ के बिचारी कहूं मारत अहारी कहूं नार के निकेत हो ॥ O Lord! Somewhere Thou art an armed warrior, somewhere Thou art an armed warrior, somewhere a learned thinker, somewhere a hunter and somewhere an enjoyer of women" WHAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Who are AKJ followers of Amabala Sahib?

Admin · 04 Sep 2006

Topic Closed.