Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

what is india culture

what is india culture

----^^^^---- · 15 Aug 2006

hindi movies and western influence has destroyed the indian culture. girls and boys are now influenced by western values. if india was to revert back to their orignal culture, what culture is that culture? what is the real indian culture? how much freedom is there to girls and boys? what is india culture minus islamic culture?

Re: what is india culture

Sitara · 15 Aug 2006

The culture that gave the world yoga, philosophy, mathematics, science, music, arts & architecture

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 15 Aug 2006

I think a purer "Indian" culture exists in the south, where they didn't have to endure the incessant invasions that people in the North had to.

Re: what is india culture

Sitara · 16 Aug 2006

South Indian culture is a "type" of Indian culture. North Indian culture does have some Middle Eastern influences - this is partly to do with invaisions but also with pre-Islamic middle eastern culture being very similar to ancient Indian culture (i.e. in Iran/Afghanistan/Mestopotmia etc) [%sig%]

Re: what is india culture

S Singh · 16 Aug 2006

Indian culture without Islamic influence is what you read about in Mahabharat and the Puraans. But you won’t find that type of culture anywhere in India anymore. Maybe it is the influence of the Islamic invasions or maybe the bad influence of Kaliyug. The Rajputs of the middle ages preserved the original Vedic Kshatiya culture to a large degree, but even that began decreasing when they joined forces with Muslim invaders.

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 16 Aug 2006

India was broke into so many components that i think it is hard to say that there was an "Indian" culture, like is being suggested. India as a united land only came about recently due to the British. When I talked to an (Indian) Bengali friend recently it really bought home how different their culture was from Panjabi. It basically differs more greatly than say that between English and French culture.

Re: what is india culture

Sitara · 17 Aug 2006

Dabir, You are right. Bengalis place more importance on education where as Punjabis place more importance on status and wealth - I know this is a broad generalisation. But I think many of the main underlying principles are the same. But if we were all the same, life would be pretty boring wouldn't it?

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 17 Aug 2006

But if we were all the same, life would be pretty boring wouldn't it? ------------------------------ Yes you are right Sitara. What i can't understand though is why systems such as Islam, "Westernism" and Hinduism try so hard to melt everyone around them into some sort of blamange. They really have problems with true diversity and try to shape those around them into their image. Alsdo I do think that there are greater differences between panjabi and bengali society than that you mentioned. Plus the thing about status and wealth is mainly a jatt preoccupation not strictly a Sikh thing.

Re: what is india culture

Sitara · 17 Aug 2006

_________ Yes you are right Sitara. What i can't understand though is why systems such as Islam, "Westernism" and Hinduism try so hard to melt everyone around them into some sort of blamange. They really have problems with true diversity and try to shape those around them into their image. _________ You are correct about Islam and Westernism but you are incorrect about Hinduism. Hinduism acccepts diversity with open arms. Nobody enforces their beliefs on Tamils, Gujaratis, Bengalis, Nepali etc etc. In Islam, for example, you have to conform to Arabic culture. For example you have to adopt Arabic names, have contempt for your original culture and pay alleigence to the two holy Mosques (Makkah and Medina).

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 17 Aug 2006

Are you kidding me Sitara, India actually classifies Sikhs as Hindus despite Sikhs repeated protests. Not allowing people to define themselves is a form of cultural imperialism and doesn't seem to be inline with what your saying. Sikh attempts to break out in their own direction is continually assaulted by Hinduism which keeps telling us we are form of them.

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 18 Aug 2006

Chandra posted: “So,” I added, “Caste is a result of this spirit of freedom and pluralism. It is something to be proud of. On the other hand, the so-called melting pot is actually a result of cultural, and often physical, extermination of diverse identities by one intolerant and powerful group.” ----------------------------------------------------------------- Caste is something to be proud of???? Represents FREEDOM!?!?!?! Try telling that to someone being oppressed by so-called higher castes. This must be the dumbest posting I've read so far.

Re: what is india culture

Sitara · 18 Aug 2006

Dalbir, __________ Are you kidding me Sitara, India actually classifies Sikhs as Hindus despite Sikhs repeated protests. __________ Oh dear, I had a feeling that this topic would turn into this useless debate in which no one benefits. But anyway this nothing to do with Hindus enforcing their culture on Sikhs it is just the Indian Government being complacent. In India, Hindus still view Sikhs as "aapney bandhey". There is not ulterior motive in this, it is just the feeling of respect they have for Sikhs however this respect has backfired on us. _______ Not allowing people to define themselves is a form of cultural imperialism and doesn't seem to be inline with what your saying. Sikh attempts to break out in their own direction is continually assaulted by Hinduism which keeps telling us we are form of them. _______ Nobody (i.e. Hindus) is holding a gun to the Sikhs head and demanding them to conform to Hindu culture - don't try and make it sound as bad as you would have everyone believe. Sikhs in India still have the right to assert their distinctiveness but most people can't be bothered to listen to them as they have more important things to worry about such as feeding their families, threats from terrorists, AIDS, Poverty, floods, drought etc etc...you know just little stupid things like that - not the really super important things in life such as Sikhs wanting a seperate identity

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 19 Aug 2006

But anyway this nothing to do with Hindus enforcing their culture on Sikhs it is just the Indian Government being complacent. In India, Hindus still view Sikhs as "aapney bandhey". There is not ulterior motive in this, it is just the feeling of respect they have for Sikhs however this respect has backfired on us. ----------------------------------- If Hindus are so loving of Sikhs how come they generally portray them as morons in their Bollywood films. Chandigarh Operation Bluestar Anand Marriage Wholesale massacre of Sikhs (84-92) Carving up Punjab into Hindi speaking states ----------------------------------------------- In India, Hindus still view Sikhs as "aapney bandhey". There is not ulterior motive in this, it is just the feeling of respect they have for Sikhs however this respect has backfired on us. --------------------------------------- With friends like this who needs enemies dude....... Please don't try that innocent crap with me, like there are no issues. India may have murdered most of the freeminded Sikhs there but we are not that simple to think it is a figment of our imagination.

Re: what is india culture

Sardar · 20 Aug 2006

Real Indian culture would include caste system. Since my ancestors were Julahe(low caste that make clothes or something i don't know maybe someone on this site probably knows better) would be treated so low. Low caste people won't be allowed to enter a Mandir. Hindus would be taking torture from Muslims and not fighting back. Invaders from Arabic countries would come and loot India and Hindus won't do anything to stop them or even fight back.

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 20 Aug 2006

Author: Chandra Singh Date: 08-18-06 07:28 "India actually classifies Sikhs as Hindus despite Sikhs repeated protests." This is news to me. ------------------------------- Well make sure you do enough background research before you come on the forum then.

Re: what is india culture

Sitara · 22 Aug 2006

_____ If Hindus are so loving of Sikhs how come they generally portray them as morons in their Bollywood films. _____ I don't know and I think it is rather stupid of them doing this. But they probably do this for the same reason you Sikhs like to potray Hindus as pathetic, weak and chalaak bahmans. Look at the Kathas by Maskeen (Hindu Anda). Do Hindu Katha Vaachaks do this type of hate filled talks? Talk about the pot calling the kettle black! ______ Invaders from Arabic countries would come and loot India and Hindus won't do anything to stop them or even fight back. ______ Are you kidding me!!! We have been fighting Invaders since 800 AD. Hear of Prithvi Raj Chauhan! But we got betrayed by some Hindus - this happend...fact of life mate. Just like when Guru Gobind Singh joined the Mughal forces

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 22 Aug 2006

Are you kidding me!!! We have been fighting Invaders since 800 AD. Hear of Prithvi Raj Chauhan! But we got betrayed by some Hindus - this happend ----------------------------------------------------- Yes, that seems to be quite a common theme these days. ...fact of life mate. Just like when Guru Gobind Singh joined the Mughal forces ------------------------------------------------ Guru Gobind(singh ji...admin) never joined the Mughal forces he was just trying to obtain justice from the state when he was moving with Bahadhur Shah. When he realised that this wasn't going to happen, he made preparations with Banda Bahadhur. The rest is history. Don't even try to put Guru Gobind(singh ji...admin) down, at least he is a reality and not the result of some twisted imagination with a elephants head, or monkey face. I feel like im in a playground now.

Re: what is india culture

ik kaur · 22 Aug 2006

"Just like when Guru Gobind Singh joined the Mughal forces" Are u crazy?? u can just say a statement like that on a Sikh forum with no backing/proof just making up some random bullshit. All the Sikhs will attack you if you dare attack our Guru. Fact of the matter is: India would be Muslim right now if it were not for Sikhs and our history of shaheedi. Yes that means you and your family. Another fact: India has been treating Sikhs as second-class citizens ever since independence, with their random police tortures, taking away of Sikhs rights, trying to eliminate us as a people by trying to change sikh history, sikh identity. So who is talking about respect backfiring on who?

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 22 Aug 2006

"But they probably do this for the same reason you Sikhs like to potray Hindus as pathetic, weak and chalaak bahmans. Look at the Kathas by Maskeen (Hindu Anda). Do Hindu Katha Vaachaks do this type of hate filled talks? Talk about the pot calling the kettle black!" I notice how you totally ignore the other points I made re: Chandigrah, Anandpur Sahib Resolution, making the Anand Marriage void, carving up Punjab into Haryana and, oh yes, the small matter of state sponsored genocide not only of militants but women and innocent men. "Just like when Guru Gobind Singh joined the Mughal forces" Guru Gobind(singh jee...admin) attempted to obtain justice from the emperor Bahadhur Shah, that is why he was with his camp. He never joined the Moghuls!!!! Seeing that no justice was forthcoming for the murder of his children, he initiated the steps that led to the destruction of Muslim rule in Punjab via Banda Bahadhur. In contrast, the cow worshipping Hill rajas DID side with the Moghuls against Guru Gobind(singh ji...admin)........after he had helped them.....sound familiar? "Are you kidding me!!! We have been fighting Invaders since 800 AD. Hear of Prithvi Raj Chauhan! But we got betrayed by some Hindus - this happend...fact of life mate." If Guru Gobind(singh ji...admin) didn't come, you probably would still be under Muslim rule to this day. Try putting Mahatma Gandhi types in front of people like that! They would make a quick snack out of him! And stop kidding yourself, Hindu resistance was crap against Muslim invaders, how many peeople in the Moghul administration were Hindus. Sycophantic cowards. In contrast Sikhs in general resisted them. Even Bulleh Shah, a contemporary, said all would be circumcised had not Guru Gobind(singh ji...admin) been around.......

Re: what is india culture

Sitara · 23 Aug 2006

<> This is from history books which by the way are not written by Bahmans. Anyway as a result of the help that was provided to the Mughals, Guru Gobind Singh was given a plot of land in Nanded in Maharashtra which is where Sachkand Sri Hazoor Sahib is. But I am in now way intending to insult yur Guru. It was probably out of majboori that he had to do this. <> This is where you are wrong. I used to believe this but after reading on Indian history, I don't hold that to be true. Sorry if this hurts your ego. The only Guru who made sacrafices for Hindus was Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji. You make it sound that Hindus have doing nothing. Fact of the matter is: India has been attacked by Muslims since 800 AD (i.e. 600+ years before Guru Nanak) if Hindus didn't fend them off, Guru Nanak would have been born in a Muslim family...and what [%sig%]

Re: what is india culture

dogra · 23 Aug 2006

Guru Gobind Singhji never joined the mugals, this really is an outrageous statement given the tremendous sacrifices made by Guruji. You ougth to apology forthwith!!

Re: what is india culture

ik kaur · 23 Aug 2006

You really have your indian history messed up. This just goes to show how much RSS Brainwashing is really working in India. EVERY Guru from Guru Nanak to Guru Gobind Singh and beyond.. to the Guru Khalsa PANTH have opposed the Invaders and their oppression and forced conversion on people; they did not do it for Hindus alone, they did it for Humanity. Just read Babbar Bani written by Guru Nanak. "Hindus didn't fend them off, Guru Nanak would have been born in a Muslim family...and what" This statement has no meaning whatsoever because Sikhism does not stem from Hinduism. Sikhism is a Revealed religion. Guru Nanak spoke the revealed truth, coming straight from Waheguru ji.

Re: what is india culture

Sitara · 24 Aug 2006

<> This is not RSS history, they eulogise Guru Gobind Singh Ji. They have extolled him so much that they see him as being no different from a Hindu devi/devta and foolishly see him as a defender of Hinduism. My source is from contemporary accounts which includes Mughal and European records. <> Most of the Gurus were pacifists. But what effect did Babur Bani have? Jehangir still continued to terrorise Hindus/Hinduism and despite this Guru Hargobind join him on a hunting expedition. Shah Jehan was just as cruel as Aurangzaib. <> In your earlier statement, you said that if it wasn't for Sikhs India would be 100% Muslim. I assume that you mean because Sikhs fought the musalmaans - that is why India did not become an Islamic nation, is this correct? What I was meant to say was that Hindus have been facing Islamic onsluaght since 800 A.D. Some of these tyrants made the Mughals look like saints. Tyrants such as Mahmud Ghaznavid, Ghori and Timur were much more wicked than Aurangzaib but we still put up a good fight because if we didn't, all of the Guru Sahibaans would have been from Muslim families going by your logic

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 25 Aug 2006

Sardarji, will you give proof or just hot air only. ------------------------------------------------------------------- Debate - Anand Marriage Act, Indian Parliament December 2003 Speech of Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann (Member of Parliament from Sangrur) in Parliament on 'Special Marriage Act, 1955 and Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, amendment Bill', moved by Hon'ble Law Minister Mr. Arun Jaitly on 09.12.2003. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Indian Parliament 9 December 2003, 1827 hrs Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann (Sangrur): Mr. Chairman, Sir, I stand on the combined strength of the Shiromani Akali Dal Badal and Mann to oppose this Bill because this Bill governs the Hindu religion. It is a revolutionary step for us, both the Akali Dals to get together and the leader of the Akali Dal Badal, Sardar Tirlochan Singh Tur has written to you that I will represent the case of the Sikhs on this matter. We are thoroughly opposed to this Bill because it ties us without our consent to the Hindu religion. Sikhism is a separate religion having a separate history, culture, language, script, traditions, territory and all the other requisites that make us a complete and wholesome religion. We may have some similarities with Hinduism but, on the other hand, Ibrahim and Moses are the common Godfathers of the Christians, Muslims and the Jews, yet they do not constitute one religion. They are poles apart. The history of the Middle East today will show you that all these three religions who accept Moses and Ibrahim as their Godfather are at daggers drawn and fighting with each other. Though we are not fighting with one another we are as different from Hinduism as the Muslim is from Judaism or of Christianity. How can Hindu leadership arbitrarily, without proof of convention, tradition and history include a separate Sikh religion within the folds of Hinduism? We consider this an insult to our pride and religious feelings. We fear that if legally and constitutionally we are not detached from the folds of Hinduism; we will be devoured into the omnivorous belly of Hinduism. To give you an example, Mr. Chairman, in the preparation of the Census population totals in the country, Sikhs are classified separately. Under the National Commission for Minorities Act, 1992, Sikhs are the distinct minority in the country………(Interruptions) Read more if you like: http://www.sikhspectrum.com/022004/debate_2003.htm

chandra you are wrong

singhsta · 26 Aug 2006

"Guru Gobind Singhji never joined the mugals, this really is an outrageous statement given the tremendous sacrifices made by Guruji." Sadly this is true. Read Jafarnama where is bragging as idol breaker to impress Aourangjeb. ----------- Chandra, you don't know anything. Guru Gobind Singh Ji never broke an idol ever in his life, show me the proof they did. What they said in Zaffarnama is that: "I am also the annihilator of the hill rajas, the idol worshippers. They are idol worshipers and I am engaged in defeating “ the very concept” of idol worship." They were symbolically speaking of stopping idol worship, by creating the path of the Khalsa. They felt that idol worship serves no purpose, so how does that mean they were trying to impress Aurangzeb. Just because our faith is against idol worship and coincidentally so is Islam, that means we are trying to impress Muslims. You should read the whole Zaffarnama in its entirety to understand its purpose. It seems at times that Guru Gobind Singh Ji is praising Aurangzeb, but in reality it is just a device to show Aurangzeb how unreligious and unrighteous he was. Don't underestimate the power of the zafarnama as Aurangzeb was so emotionally distraught after reading it, that he requested an immediate meeting with Guru Gobind Singh Ji. By the way, it was your HINDU HILL RAJAS WHO SIDED WITH THE MUGHALS. They were consistently harrassing the Khalsa around Anandpur Sahib and each time the Khalsa gave them a crushing defeat. That is why they had to RUN TO AURANGZEB AND ASK FOR HELP. THey tried to portray Guru Gobind Singh Ji a threat to Islam, when in reality they knew the Khalsa was a threat to all high caste Hindus. Nobody except for Guru Gobind Singh Ji could have transformed the low caste Hindu from sheeps to LIONS.

Re: chandra you are wrong

Sitara · 27 Aug 2006

<> The Hindu Hill Rajas gave the Sikhs sanctuary after the Shaheedi of Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji but the Sikhs started to take advantage of the Hill Rajas and so they complained to the Mughals. It was only then that Guru Gobind Singh began to arm his followers. As a Hindu I feel that the Hindu Hill Rajas should not have gone to Mussalmaans (i.e. Mughals) for help, but that is history now...even Rajputs have a History of collaborating with invaders and I am man enough to admit this. Also how was it that Guru Gobind Singh birthplace was Patna in the Eastern state of Bihar? The reason being was that Guru Tegh Bahadur assisted the Mughals in a military expedition to Assam against the Assamese Hindu kings <> Shivaji was a low cast Hindu...did he take amrit from Guru Sahib?

Re: what is india culture

dogra · 27 Aug 2006

Again an apology is required. For heavens sake the words given to Aurangzeb are words, they are not actions. Gurujis actions are well known, as has been said on Guruji" he appeared as a herald of courage and fortitiude for his countrymen". To doubt these deeds, the death of his beloved father and 4 sons is quite frankly an outrage and insult to the memory. Guruji also went to Nanda Devi Temple, which is not that far from Anandpur Sahib

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 27 Aug 2006

Shivaji was a low cast Hindu...did he take amrit from Guru Sahib? --------------------------------------------- Yeah but he is a figure of history now, whereas Guru Gobind Singh Ji has millions of followers to this day so............

Re: what is india culture

Sitara · 28 Aug 2006

<> I don't know about you but most Hindus (including mysel) are inspired from both these personalities. But anyway my point was in response to Singhsta's statement. Shivaji was not a Guru or religious leader so your point is not valid.

Question for chandra

singhsta · 28 Aug 2006

I can't believe you would even think for a second that Guru Gobind Singh Ji broke any idols. Even if you read a wrong translation of the Zaffarnama, you should know better than that. Give me one example anywhere in history of Guru Gobind Singh Ji invading a Hindu mandir and breaking idols. Yes they did destroy man idol-worshippers (the hill rajas), but where does that imply they destryoed idols. WHat do you think Guru Gobind Singh Ji was, Mohammad? Guru Ji respected every religion and never persecuted any Muslims or Hindus. If you don't know by know, the main principle in our religion is not conversion. As seen by the Sri Guru Granth Sahib, we believe, Hindus should be good hindus, Muslims should be good Muslims and Sikhs should be good Sikhs. We might not agree with many aspects of other religions, but we still RESPECT them, as they are other peoples beliefs and they choose to believe them.

Re: what is india culture

Singh · 28 Aug 2006

"But he transformed millions of low caste sheeps into Lions without giving or taking amrit." are you trying to say that the amrit of Guru Gobind Singh jee is of no use? shivaji was a political leader and Guru Gobind Singh jee was a spiritual leader. there is no comparison here. this kind of hatred of sikh gurus is quite prevalent in hindus. when they say they respect sikh gurus, they are doing only lip service. just read the posts of sitara and other hindus under this thread.

Re: what is india culture

Dalbir · 28 Aug 2006

But he transformed millions of low caste sheeps into Lions without giving or taking amrit. ----------------------------- I'm not saying he didn't achieve great things (Shivaji) but Guru Gobind Singh Ji created a new philosophy that still inspires to this day and his followers have been at the forefront against oppression since. Shivaji is a historical figure whose vibe has petered out since his passing. Guru Gobind Singh is still alive and kicking in this respect.

chandra doesn't like to read

singhsta · 28 Aug 2006

Didn't you read my previous post where I told you that you are reading an incorrect translation. Guru Gobind Singh Ji is saying that they are against the CONCEPT of idol worship and hence teaching Sikhs to stop ("break") it. They are not literally saying that they are breaking idols, they are breaking the practice of idol worship amongst Sikhs. If you still don't understand, read the following website which explains tranlating the zafarnama line by line. You can go and read the line referring to idol "breaking". If you still think that is wrong, show one proof in any source of Guru Gobind Singh Ji breaking an idol. I will bet you a million dollars you will never find it.

Re: what is india culture

Sitara · 29 Aug 2006

___________ I'm not saying he didn't achieve great things (Shivaji) but Guru Gobind Singh Ji created a new philosophy that still inspires to this day and his followers have been at the forefront against oppression since. Shivaji is a historical figure whose vibe has petered out since his passing. Guru Gobind Singh is still alive and kicking in this respect. ___________ Same can be said for other religious figures such as Jesus Christ, Buddha, Muhammed, Moses....the point you are trying to make is sill invalid. You are comparing apples with oranges (i.e. you are not doing a like for like comparison).

Re: what is india culture

Sitara · 29 Aug 2006

<> This is your bruised ego speaking now. I haven’t made derogatory statements against the Gurus I have just made statements that you find uncomfortable and all you can come out with is that Hindus hate sikh gurus. I have absolutely no hatred for the Guru Sahibaan.

Re: what is india culture

fresno sikh · 29 Aug 2006

SSAKAL As Guru Gobind singh ji says per Bhai Santokh singh hindus and Muslims will go blind with dirt in their eyes trying to destroy the Khalsa* . But my khalsa will live forever. Two big mistakes made by our stupid so called sikh leaders were not getting a independent state in 1947 and refusing to let Ambedkar and millions of low caste abused hindus to get in the sikh panth. So we are now paying heavy price now by piggy back the looser hindu-indian culture as monkey on our back. Note: Ref to Bhai Santokh Singh's Teeka by Sodhi Teja Singh [%sig%]

Re: what is india culture

dogra · 30 Aug 2006

How pathetic! Anyone who talks of partition, is ignoring the simple fact: THE MAJORITY OF PEOPLE DID NOT VOTE FOR PARTITION. It was against the humanistic and democratic principles. Wonder how many people disprove of the palestine Partition by creation of the Jewish State???? It should never be forgotten that people of all faiths lived together peacefully b4 partition.

Re: what is india culture

fresno sikh · 30 Aug 2006

Fact of the matter is that Sikh's need a separate homeland to look out for their own intrest. Do not patronize me I stand firm on my ideology Dogra. Betrayer of the sikhs. Without whom the sikh kingdom would have lived much longer.

Re: what is india culture

dogra · 01 Sep 2006

I am not patronizing you, and dont patronize me with that betrayer line. Maharaja Ranjit Singhji was a secular ruler. Fact of the matter Partition was illegal, and i stand firm in my ideological beliefs!! RAM MOHAMMED SINGH AZAD-SHAHEED UDHAM SINGHJI

Re: what is india culture

navjot2 · 01 Sep 2006

hello all firstly i must say that i am quite dismayed at the behaviour of some sikhs here. i see alot of arrogance and aggression on display. i urge you to consider your behaviour. it is rude, and inaccurate, to say things such as 'oh sikhs saved you' to hindus. please do away with such ignorant behaviour, as it is a disservice to the panth. i would like to point out a few important points. 1. Gurus and their sikhs only fought in defence, not offence. Sikhs did not have territorial ambitions. the maratha rebel Shivaji fought for nationhood. he used war games to win freedom for his people (like a general/military leader would). these are two differant categories of people and it does not make sense to compare them. 2. It is not proven that 'zafar namah' is infact Guru Gobind Singhs work, partially or entirely. for example, there is another competing text called 'Fatehnama', which is differant. "How did the Zafarnama, in its present form, reach us? Original letter written in the hand of Guru Ji in not available. However it is said that a copy of Zafarnama, written in the hand of Guru Ji, was found with the Mahant of Patna Sahib in 1890 and one Babu Jagan Nath made a copy; this copy was somehow misplaced by him. Since Babu Jagan Nath was himself a scholar in Persian language, he could reproduce it from his memory and got it printed in Nagri Parcharni Patrika in Benaras. He is also believed to have sent a copy to Sardar Umrao Singh Shergill in Amritsar who is said to have given it to Khalsa college and which in turn reproduced in Makhz-e Twarikh Sikhan. In Punjab newspapers, it first appeared in the Khalsa Samachar of 16 July 1942. Then in 1944, Sardar Kapur Singh ICS published it in Urdu Ajit of Lahore under the heading "Fatehnama". It is quite possible that in the process of translations and publications of Zafarnama at different stages, some verses were not reproduced correctly and what we have today is not the original Zafarnama of Guru Ji in its entirety. The abrupt end of Zafarnama also indicates that it is not complete and that some verses have been left out. Objections raised by some scholars on the authenticity of a few verses may be viewed in this context." (http://www.zafarnama.com/) Note that this 'new' version appeared whilst there was political tumult and the 'divide and conquer' policy was bearing fruit. 3. i do not know where this idea that 'Guru Gobind was born in Bihar because Guru Tegh Bahadur was accompanying the moghuls there' came from. if i am not mistaken, it was a hindu raja who was going to assam. there was a sizeable dharamsala in Bihar from Guru Nanak's visit. Guru Tegh Bahadur went across to visit the sangat. the hindu raja and his camp met the Guru and enjoined his camp. 4. and all this talk of Gobind Singh meeting with Bahadur Shah in south india: Earlier Bahadur Shah, as a young prince, was known to be liberal unlike Aurangzeb: "Following the appointment in 1694 of the liberal Prince Muazzam (later Emperor Bahadur Shah) as viceroy of northwestern region including Punjab, there was however a brief respite from pressure from the ruling authority." http://www.sikh-history.com/sikhhist/gurus/nanak10.html Gurus were Holy men and did not have hate for people, only compassion. they would not have scolded Aurangzeb's son for the wrongs of his father. i am a not a very learned person, yet i contribute what i understand in order to clear up some misunderstandings and false assumptions. i ask that fellow sikhs on here communicate with humilty, honesty and respect for themselves and all others, and not with vanity, arrogance and false pride. [%sig%]