regarding pronouncing "sihari"
niyarakhalsa -a complete idiot · 15 Aug 2006
Please before we start this topic..lets not digress into brickbatting Mohinder SIngh SDO or anyone for not following what we might concider as right.
Now the the question , I was hearing some keertan by Sdo ji from the site Shabad Vartara. While doing keertan he pronounces the sihari on the last letters of the word .( we know that the sihari has a lot of significance and clarifies a lot of meenings . )
I just want to ask , if anyone knows , is he the first one to pronounce it like this ?
Is there any document / book related to this pronounciation ?
is there any book / research that deals with correct pronounciation?
I know this is a controversial topic . please refrain form giving personal views , I need guidance.
[%sig%]
Re: regarding pronouncing "sihari"
Kulbir Singh · 15 Aug 2006
Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara was in favour of pronouncing Siharis in the end and he has written about it in his book on Gurbani Viyakaran and also in his book on Gurbani Ucharan.
Another person other than SDO, who favours pronouncing siharis is Dr Harkirat Singh who has written a book on Gurbani viyakaran.
I know, some Singhs in olden times used to pronounce siharis in the end.
The mainstream Panth keeps the siharis and aunkars of nouns silent. Siharis and aunkars. of verbs are pronounced. I personally favour and practice this but if someone wants to pronounce siharis and aunkars, I have no problem with them.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: regarding pronouncing "sihari"
Harmeet Singh · 15 Aug 2006
Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa || Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh ||
I was just listening to a recording of SDO the other day and yes he would pronounce: Ad Sach, Jugad Sach, Haa Bhee Sach, Nanak Hosee Bhee Sach|| ....to: Ad Sachi, Jugad Sachi, Haa Bhee Sachi, Nanak Hosee Bhee Sachi||
I don't believe it's wrong..everyone has their own opinions and no one will ever be able to pronounce any word of Gurbani perfectly the way Guru Jee wrote it and sung it.
Just a side note.. please don't turn this into a Bhai Mohinder Singh Jee SDO bashing topic as he was a great man with great knowledge of Gurbani (more than any of us have including myself). Yes he did make a mistake and was summoned to Akal Takhat Sahib and he asked for forgiveness and was forgived. He was one of the main Sangat members who created all of these 'AKJ' tunes (other than Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Jee)...
Most of the tunes you hear by Dulla Jee and many other of your favourites are mostly made by him so please don't turn this into a topic to bash Mohinder Singh Jee SDO or to slander him..he is a man of great knowledge...
Bhul Chuk Maph Karnee Jee
Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa || Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh ||
Re: regarding pronouncing "sihari"
niyarakhalsa -a complete idiot · 15 Aug 2006
I request the moderator to stop this topic .
my question regarding the pronounciation has been answered by kulbeer SIngh ji. I will be buying the books recomended. ( I hope i will be able to get them at chater Singh jevan singh at New Delhi ) .
now the topic is digressing in the wrong direction . We sitting on our pc's cant change SDO ji or any one else when he/she is not a part of our discussion . And discusiing people is not our aim.
( allready a lot of damage has been done by personality cults : for eg. we concider all our role models like Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale ; Bhai sahib Randheer SIngh ; Sirdar Kapoor Singh ; Kahn Singh Nabha etc. as unfailable .... that they can never do any mistake ... and are ready to take out kirpans and fight if anyone says that here on this little point they made a mistake .... take the case of ragmala itself ... we revere both bhai sahib Randheer singh and Gurbachan singh Khalsa bhindranwale and both had opposite views....we are ready to fight & kill !
But we forget one point which is the basis on both sides i.e. immense love and faith on Guru Granth Sahib , that prompts them to take their respective stands. and people are people , they make mistakes ( bhullan ander sabh ko , abhull guru Kartar ) )
lets do our own gyan gosht with our shabad guru Guru Granth Shaib and find our own answers ... that seems to be only way .....
Sorry for being so single tracked in making this request for closing the topic.
[%sig%]