Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

aanjan · 11 Aug 2006

What does Allah refer to in Gurbani? What do Hindoo character names refer to in gurbani? RSS always says that the Ram is the one who lost his wife and the Ram word in Siri Guru Granth Sahib refers to that Ram.

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

aman · 12 Aug 2006

Ram is not that Ram who lost his wife but almighty God.Almighty God has many names Waheguroo, Ram , Allah , God.

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

daas_harveen_singh_manchester · 13 Aug 2006

wjkkwjkf! Allah is just another word for god which is used in gurbani very rarely but its used. and allah doesn't mean muslims god, that is just the word they use for god. whenever you see ram with an onkarh at the bottom of the mamma, it means god. it is very rare that you see ram without an onkarh at the bottom of the mamma. the hindu ram is not the same ram which is mentioned in bani. example: raam ras peeaa rae || I drink in the sublime essence of the LORD(ram).

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Sitara · 13 Aug 2006

OK point made....anything else or are you going to keep recycling these unproductive discussions??? Personally (as a Hindu) I feel that Sikhs ARE seperate from Hindus and I find it embarassing when Hindus try an convince the arrogant Sikhs that this is not the case

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

----^^^^---- · 14 Aug 2006

allah, raam, shaam, gopal, gobind, bhagwan, all mean the same - God. different names have been used to describe god's different qualities. raam means omnipresent. shaam means beautiful and so on. raam of auyodha was a good king but not god. same holds true for krishna. allah was the moon god of arabs but for sikhs this name is used to refer to one almighty God.

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Kulbir Singh · 15 Aug 2006

My meagre understanding of the Mahavaaks quoted by Chandra Singh is as follows: Siri Guru jee is saying that the Guru form of Vaheguru was prevalent in all avatars who came on Earth. In Satyug, Siri Guru jee did his works through the Vaaman Avatar and prevented King Bali from taking on the three worlds. In Treta, he worked through Raam Avatar and killed Ravan. In Duapar he worked through Krishna Murari and killed Kansa and gave the kingdom to Ugarsain. But all this time the individuality of these avatars and Siri Guru jee was different. But what happened in Kalyug? Kaljug Parmaan Nanak Gur, Angad, Amar kahaiyo|| Siri Guru Raaj Abichal Attal, Aad Purakh Furmaiyo|| (In Kalyug the Guru form of Vaheguru - Siri Satguru came out in open and called himself Guru Nanak, Guru Angad and Guru Amardaas jee. Aad Purakh i.e. Vaheguru declared that Siri Guru jee's kingdom is eternal). Clearly we see that in the previous yugs, Siri Guru jee was working in the avatars of those yugs but in Kalyug, Siri Guru jee himself took on the human form (notice the word Parmaan). The status of the avatars of previous yugs is quite high. They were not ordinary beings and as per Gurbani they did good works when they came. Yes, some errors too were committed as written by Siri Dasmesh jee but they did fulfill the purpose of their avatars. According to Gurbani, at the time of their great deeds, Siri Guru jee were behind them. The power was derived from the Guru form of Vaheguru. This Guru form came to Earth in Kalyug in the form of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. [%sig%]

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

jagroop singh · 15 Aug 2006

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer Chandra Singh Ji, i don't know if Ram of Auyodha is the same as Ram Chander but is that is the case, the following Pankti may interest you: "Kabir, call him Ram who is All-Present; we must make distinction between two 'Rams'. The One Ram is contained in All. Ram Chander is only contained in one thing, himself." (Bhagat Kabir Sahib, Saloks) If Guru Sahib is indeed talking about the same Ram, then there can be no other way to look at aside from the perspective Veer Kulbir Singh Ji has put forward. Because that would be the only way to assimilate the panktis you have put forward with the pankti above. After all, Ram Chander is being described as something other than Immortal / Eternal int he above pankti.

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Roopkaur · 15 Aug 2006

Who was Bhagat Kabir Ji's guru anyways? It is clear from Bhagat ji's bani that they did have a guru, and thought it absolutely necessary to meet the satguru inorder to meet Vaheguru. Though at one point they may have been the disciple of Ramanand, at the time of writing the bani which is included in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, , this cannot be the case. Ramanand was a wroshipper of Ram, and he worshipped the sargun form. However Bhagat Ji state that they worshipped the Nirgun Akaal Purkh. The only guru of the time that promoted Nirgun worship of Akaal Purkh was Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji. At the time of writing the bani which is in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Bhagat Ji's Guru was dhan dhan Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji. [%sig%]

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Mehtab Singh · 15 Aug 2006

Does anyone notice the massive difference in Kabir jee's writings that Hindus refer to as [i]dohay[/i], and the Gurbani shabads in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee? They are totally different! [%sig%]

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Sitara · 16 Aug 2006

That is probably because they are different Kabirs. As Kulbir Singh has said before, the Kabir whose baanis are in SGGS was a chela of Siri Guru Nanak Dev Ji. The Kabir that Hindus follow was born a 100 or so years ago before Guru Nanak

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Kulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2006

Sitara jeeo, I see that your recent posts are in bad taste. Cheer up my friend. Don't take anything personal. Khush raho. I never wrote that there were two Kabirs. My stand has always been that Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and Bhagat Kabir jee did cross paths and met. It is written in old Sikh manuscripts that Siri Guru jee met Bhagat Ramanand jee and all his chelas at Ayodhya. Details of one of the most interesting conversation between Siri Guru jee and Swami Ramanand is written there. In the end, Swami Ramanand jee adopted Gurmat from Guru Sahib. All bhagats followed Swami jee and adopted Siri Guru jee' Gurmat. After becoming Bhagats of Nirgun Vaheguru, they wrote baani and its this baani that is in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. The baani that Bhagat Kabir jee wrote before adopting Gurmat is not in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. I have written enough on this. Please refer to old posts for details. [%sig%]

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Gurdaspuria · 16 Aug 2006

Waheguru jee ka Khalsa Waheguru jee ke Fateh I am disappointed to read this thread. A number of writers of the tread violated basic Sikhism foundation principles. I will not be specific to the writers. Please evaluate yourself if your message reply holds true the following verses and the foundation principles of Sikhism: 1) Akal Purkh never took birth, died or reincarnated. Please read the following sabad for details about Krishna. so mukh jalo jith kehehi t(h)aakur jonee ||3|| Let that mouth be burnt, which says that our Lord and Master is subject to birth. ||3|| Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Bhairao 1136 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=4063 2) Bhagat Pehlad is satjug era’s Bhagat recited RAM RAM raam kehai kar thaal bajaavai chatteeaa sabhai bigaarae ||1|| He chants the Lord's Name RAM, clapping his hands to keep the beat; he has spoiled all the other students. ||1|| Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Bhairao 1165 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=4154 This Shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Salok Kabeer Jee on Pannaa 1374 kabeer raamai raam kahu kehibae maahi bibaek || eaek anaekehi mil gaeiaa eaek samaanaa eaek ||191|| Kabeer, use the word 'Raam', only to speak of the All-pervading Lord. You must make that distinction. One 'Raam' is pervading everywhere, while the other(Ram Chander) is contained only in himself. ||191|| http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=G&PageNo=&ShabadID=5159&Format=2 3) Ram Chander was a exiled King of treta era who had fight with Ravan for his wife. Ram Chander was not reincarnation of God or avtar paa(n)ddae thumaraa raamacha(n)dh so bhee aavath dhaekhiaa thhaa || Raavan saethee sarabar hoee ghar kee joe gavaaee thhee ||3|| O Pandit, I saw your Raam Chand coming too; he lost his wife, fighting a war against Raawan. ||3|| Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Raag Gond 875 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=3268 rovai raam nikaalaa bhaeiaa || Rama wept when he was sent into exile, Guru Nanak Dev Ji Raag Raamkalee 953 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=3491 4) Following Gurbani verses establish relationship between Guru Nanak, Satguru and God naanak sathigur breham dhikhaaeiaa ||5||20|| O Nanak, the True Guru has shown me the Lord God. ||5||20|| Guru Nanak Dev Ji Raag Aasaa 355 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=1389 sathigur maelee bhai vasee naanak praem sakhaae ||8||2|| The True Guru has led me to meet Him, and now I dwell in the Fear of God. O Nanak, His Love is always with me. ||8||2|| Guru Nanak Dev Ji Siree Raag 54 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=155 eaeko naam hukam hai naanak sathigur dheeaa bujhaae jeeo ||5|| The One Name is the Lord's Command; O Nanak, the True Guru has given me this understanding. ||5|| Guru Nanak Dev Ji Siree Raag 72 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=182 Waheguru jee ka Khalsa Waheguru jee ke Fateh

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Sitara · 17 Aug 2006

Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, Believe it or not I actually have an immense respect for you (as I am sure many people on this board have). I think you are very intelligent and knowledgeable but more importantly I think you are a very sincere person in terms of following the principles of Gurmat. You have said somethings that I as a Hindu found very offensive but looking back I honestly feel that you had no malice (unlike many of the posters on this board) in these statements you made. In this respect I may have over-reacted and said somethings which were out of character. I hope there are no hard feelings Fateh Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Gurdaspuria · 17 Aug 2006

Chanda, I don't have any argument with you ( Hindu) You can believe whatever your religion says, we have no problem. Please note that our(Sikh) pathway to approach God is different. - Our Gurus and bhagats never claimed there were God. - They (Gurus and bhagats) and us (the sikhs) are Khalsa/servent of Waheguru, and we always celebrate with Naam - the glories of Waheguru. If you want to know about Gurmat, please read the the whole sabad: bhairo mehalaa 5 ghar 1 ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh || sagalee thheeth paas ddaar raakhee || asattam thheeth govi(n)dh janamaa see ||1|| bharam bhoolae nar karath kacharaaein || janam maran thae rehath naaraaein ||1|| rehaao || kar pa(n)jeer khavaaeiou chor || ouhu janam n marai rae saakath dtor ||2|| sagal paraadhh dhaehi loronee || so mukh jalo jith kehehi t(h)aakur jonee ||3|| janam n marai n aavai n jaae || naanak kaa prabh rehiou samaae ||4||1|| Bhairao, Fifth Mehla, First House: One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: Setting aside all other days, it is said that the Lord was born on the eighth lunar day. ||1|| Deluded and confused by doubt, the mortal practices falsehood. The Lord is beyond birth and death. ||1||Pause|| You prepare sweet treats and feed them to your stone god. God is not born, and He does not die, you foolish, faithless cynic! ||2|| You sing lullabyes to your stone god - this is the source of all your mistakes. Let that mouth be burnt, which says that our Lord and Master is subject to birth. ||3|| He is not born, and He does not die; He does not come and go in reincarnation. The God of Nanak is pervading and permeating everywhere. ||4||1|| http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=4063"""" Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee kee Fateh

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Gurdaspuria · 17 Aug 2006

Chandra, End of discussion from my end

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

WJKK WJKF! · 17 Aug 2006

chandra ji what point are you trying to make? are you saying we should worship ram chander or krishna etc? are you trying to imply perhaps us sikhs are denying our "hindu origins" if indeed we had any. "What if your religion and my religion clash?" gurbani is ultimate truth and gurbani says: [gurbani]sB qy vfw siqguru nwnku ijin kl rwKI myrI ]4]10]57][/gurbani] sabh thae vaddaa sathigur naanak jin kal raakhee maeree ||4||10||57|| Guru Nanak is the greatest of all; He saved my honor in this Dark Age of Kali Yuga. ||4||10||57|| <<<<<<<<<<<< sri guru arjan dev ji doesnt mention raam chander or krishna as saving us from kalyug. maharaj clearly states guru nanak dev ji as "sabh te vadda". there is clearly a reason why guru nanak had to come from sahckhand himself in iron age, because its the worst and darkest age and the world needs a leader which is truely up to the job. satguru nanak came and established sikh panth and gurmat along with all gurus up to present guru granth sahib, who infact were all same jyot of nanak. many times has guru gobind singh stated he has no faith in anyone else but the immortal akal purakh. if you are trying to imply that sikhs are supposed to meditate upon krishna or raam chander, then that will not lead anyone anywhere. they were all perishable, maharaj has clearly drirected sikhs to meditate on ever present formless waheguru. even guru gobind singh said dont worship me worship akal purakh waheguru even tho maharaj himself was a form of waheguru. i do not think, tho they might have done alot of good aswel that raam chander was on the sme level as guru gobind singh and therefore satguru nanak. after all he is the satguru of the darkest age. which means satguru nanak is the special person to undertake the hardest job of all, i.e saving this world from the darkest age by establishing the hardest dharam to follow i.e gurmat. khalsa will indeed prevail. there would not hve been a need for guru nanak to come to this world if the previous dharams had upheld rightousness and not adopted pakhand and worshiped perishable devteh. it is clear all through gurbani that we should worship the perminant akal purakh. guru gobind singh says in dasam granth that many prophets of other dharams suffered from ego as a result of some of their actions. guru ji himself was near enough waheguru he was manifestation of bani which cme from sachkhand yet maharaj still has humility to say worship waheguru not me. idolising devteh etc will not sve u in this age my friend, adopt the religion of naam simran and gd deeds, become humble. surrender to formless permanant akal. this is just das's two cents worth, if das is wrong in any point made gursikho plz correct me and pardon my mistakes das is just a learner also. sorry for any offense chander to your dharam, alot of sikhs do not like to brag about our dharam we prefer to follow it instead. tho sometimes debate has to be indulged in to educate others and indeed ourselves. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Harinder Singh · 17 Aug 2006

Its a waste of time explanining anything to Chandra,the DEBATER. He will keep on using his "cleverness" to somehow keep on writing and arguing. But this cleverness of Chandra wont save him from Jamdoots though.

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Harjas Kaur · 17 Aug 2006

[quote]But this cleverness of Chandra wont save him from Jamdoots though.[/quote] He already has mind parasites and doesn't know it. [quote]Don't force the message of the great Gurus into monotheistic moulds and make it mere a mimicry of books of divine gangsterism. [/quote] ੴ ਸਤਿ ਨਾਮੁ ਕਰਤਾ ਪੁਰਖੁ ਨਿਰਭਉ ਨਿਰਵੈਰੁ ਅਕਾਲ ਮੂਰਤਿ ਅਜੂਨੀ ਸੈਭੰ ਗੁਰ ਪ੍ਰਸਾਦਿ ॥ ੴ सति नामु करता पुरखु निरभउ निरवैरु अकाल मूरति अजूनी सैभं गुर प्रसादि ॥ ik-oNkaar sat naam kartaa purakh nirbha-o nirvair akaal moorat ajoonee saibhaN gur parsaad. One Universal Creator God. The Name Is Truth. Creative Being Personified. No Fear. No Hatred. Image Of The Undying, Beyond Birth, Self-Existent. By Guru's Grace ~ -SGGS P.1 Sikhi is predicated on the singularity of the Divine, i.e., monotheism, by the very utterance of the Guru who is One Jyot. [quote]Don't let Sikhism to take the path of a exclusiveness, self-righteousness, self-aggrandizement. Don't use terror in the service of religion,[/quote] "Exclusiveness," i.e., individual identity separate from Hinduism. "Self-righteousness," i.e., righteous without needing parasitical moorings in another religion like Hinduism for spiritual completion. "Self-aggrandizement," i.e., Divine spiritual dignity of the Lions of God. "Terror in the service of religion," i.e., as in self-defense against Hindutva forces compelling genocide or submission into Hindu identity. Sikhs never started any war of conversion or submission, neither do they submit anywhere in history. What exactly is your message Chandra Singh? You are twisting realities to suit a political agenda. Dear Chandra, as someone with a background in what you term "Abrahamic "religions...please note: "Very truly I tell you," Jesus answered, "before Abraham was born, I am!" -John 8:58 Could you please explain this Christian verse? It seems your antagonism to Abrahamic religions has to do with Indian Intelligence agencies fear of monotheistic religions such as Sikhi asserting independance rather than any spiritual dialogue mutually respecting any one else's beliefs. [%sig%]

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Harjas Kaur · 18 Aug 2006

[quote]Most of the people think that i am an RSS/arya samaji/Hindu etc. Hence need to be ridiculed and mocked and hence 99.9% of the people quoting Banis with Monotheistic paint put by Khlaistanis. [/quote] Well, you seem to think that Sikhism is an extension of Hindu religion, and that Khalistanis are a part of some Abrahamic cult, despite the fact that many of them have been scholars of Gurbani. And you continue to promote the same extremist Hindutva agenda as BJP/RSS, etc. So what are people to think? I don't see ridicule or mockery of you, just complete disavowal of your ideas. I actually find some of your posts interesting. [quote]" But this cleverness of Chandra wont save him from Jamdoots though." Don't you think you are appropriating a Hindu God to scare a Hindu?. [/quote] Only Hindutva fanatics coin phrases like Abrahamic versus Indic. Sikhism is monotheistic...although it recognizes the existance of beings by different names which the Hindu's call gods/devas/asuras, although not as being God which is only ONE. In fact, Islam, Judaism, Christianity even Buddhism also recognize the spiritual reality of these other beings, but do not recognize them as the ONE God, or in Buddhism, the ultimate shunyata. No one is appropriating anything. Just because other faiths recognize certain truths in Hindu religion does not make these religions subordinate to Hinduism. All these other faiths find differences and errors in Hindu religion as well. That's why they aren't Hindu. It's very simple Chandra, really. Hindu's read the Vedas. Sikhs read the Siri Guru Granth Sahibji. If our Guruji talks about Vedantic concepts or Islamic concepts, all that a Sikh needs to know is what is offered in Guru's explanations. We do not need to go read the Vedas or the Q'uran for understanding. [%sig%]

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

aanjan · 18 Aug 2006

****** Then how Khalsa will be victorious?. Are you a hawk of guru Saheb or just a dove worth making some sound only. ****** Khalsa will be victorious by staying NIARA and far from Idol worship/bhoot worship. ******* "You can believe whatever your religion says, we have no problem." What if your religion and my religion clash? ******* We will not attack you unless provoked but at the same time will not be sitting ducks and know how to return 'bhaji'. ******* "- Our Gurus and bhagats never claimed there were God." LOL!!!. are you saying sikhism is a doctrine of atheism? "They (Gurus and bhagats) and us (the sikhs) are Khalsa/servent of Waheguru, and we always celebrate with Naam - the glories of Waheguru." How are you diffrent from a hip-hop fan?. who celebrate on the name of their idol singer. ******** You still have not answered why you dont make Idols out of s**t or maybe cows poo?

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Harjas Kaur · 19 Aug 2006

[quote]What makes you to translate "ik-oNkaar" to "One Universal " and "kartaa purakh" to Creator God?.[/quote] English is not an exact replica of Gurbani Chandra. That's why Panj Pyare tell people taking amrit to learn Punjabi and Gurmukhi. A lot of meaning is lost otherwise. There is great depth of meaning. Layers and layers of meaning in Gurbani. I own 4 English gutkas, and all of them differ somewhat in English translation. Even online translations have some difference trying to better capture Gurbani concepts in English words which are not exact counterparts. Ik = One. "ik-oNkaar" "There is only one God" "One Universal" "Immanent in His Creation" "That which was, is, will be, is all Onkar. And that which triple transcends is Onkar too." "A Being which is outside the limits of time and space." u·ni·ver·sal: Of, relating to, extending to, or affecting the entire world or all within the world; worldwide. Of or relating to the universe or cosmos; cosmic. [quote] 'O-ankaar' denotes that God manifests Himself ceaselessly throughout His Creation in diverse forms, features and colours, and in this way becomes knowable to man. But, in spite of manifesting Himself diversing, God remains One; He remains Immanent in His Creation, while at the same time remaining Transcendent. This God is at once One and Many implying Unity in Diversity. Kapur Singh suggests Oan = Transcedent, -kar = Immanent. The Mandukopanishad defines the word as: "That which was, is, will be, is all Onkar. And that which triple transcends is Onkar too." http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php?title=Mool_Mantar[/quote] "kartaa purakh" "Creator God" "God, the Supreme Being, Himself is the Creator (Kartaa), and being immanent in His Creation, is All Pervasive and fills all beings (Purakh)." Cre·a·tor: the supernatural being conceived as the perfect and omnipotent and omniscient originator and ruler of the universe. One that creates. God. [quote]The Creator Karta translates literally as the Doer, the Creator. Purukh translates literally as man, husband, basically a male person. In the Sankhya system of Hindu philosophy, Purusha (the Universal Spirit), eternal, indestructible, all pervasive, is without activity or attribute, and if it is left to Prakriti (primal nature), itself an uncaused cause, and an ultimate principle, to bring the phenomenal world into being. The Sikh doctrine, however, while making use of the word, emphasizes Purusha being Himself and only Creator. As in Sufi and Vaishnavic lore, He is the only He, His creatures being females longing to go out and Unite with Him. Dr.Santokh Singh says: God, the Supreme Being, Himself is the Creator (Kartaa), and being immanent in His Creation, is All Pervasive and fills all beings (Purakh). He is thus Omniscient, knowing each one's inner mind, and Omnipotent, doing everything everywhere - evoluting, sustaining, and involuting. By stating God as the Creator, one may think that the Creator and His creation to be separate. When man sculpts an idol and the idol is completed, the sculptor and the sculpture are no longer one; they are separate. And the sculpture will remain long after the sculptor is dead. If the image fractures, the sculptor is not also broken, because the two are separate. There is no such distance between God and His creation. http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php?title=Mool_Mantar[/quote] [quote]SikhSpectrum.com Monthly Issue No.12, May 2003 Time, Reality and Religion: The Vedantic and Sikh Conception by Jasbir Singh Ahluwalia Ik Onkar, Sat Nam, Karta Purakh and Akal Murat. The first term refers to the in-itself, indeterminate essence of the ultimate reality which is supra-temporal (Akal Murat) vis-a-vis the realm of time and space created by the Absolute as the creative Spirit (Karta Purakh). The Absolute through the creative act becomes determine reality- Sat Nam- in the sense of determinate Infinity as against the abstract Infinity given by the category of Ik Onkar. As it is in the creative act that the abstract Infinite becomes the determinate Infinity, so the created realm comes to be seen as a determination of the Absolute, which in the Sikh idiom is called His Name: All that He has created is His name.30 The Sanskrit word sat, like the English term being, refers neither to the ideal nor to the material aspect of reality; it rather, connotes the logical aspect under which all that can be said is, that the Real is. In their abstractness the Vedantic (nirguna) Brahman (Being) and Buddhist Shunyata (Nothingness) tend to be indistinguishable from each other, for the simple reason that when the ultimate reality is seen as excludent of all determinations, qualities, attributes and predicates, then, there remains no (epistemological) way of distinguishing Being from Nothingness. As such, though epistemologically there remains no determinate distinction between the Vedantic Brahman and the Buddhist Shunyata, yet the former is posited in the logical aspect of "isness". Brahman, while sharing its indeterminacy and abstractness with the Buddhist Shunyata, is sat: Being-in-itself. It was to emphasize such logical "beingness," (isness) of the (nirguna, nirankar) Absolute that Guru Nanak placed Ik -the numerical one- (as a sign of positivity in contrast to the Buddhist negativity given by the term Shunyata) to constitute the term Ik Onkar to symbolize “beingness” (isness) of the Absolute, notwithstanding its abstractness and indeterminacy. Having thus contradistinguished his doctrine from the Buddhist concept, Guru Nanak, then, proceeds to differentiate it from the Vedantic Brahman which is sat not Sat Nam. In other words, Guru Nanak does not rest content merely with positing the logical being (sat) of the ultimate reality, but goes on to make the indeterminate Absolute manifest itself as determinate Infinity, Sat Nam, in, the creative act qua Spirit. Thus the term Sat Nam does not mean that "His Name is Truth", or that "His Reality is Eternal". It would be much more appropriate to render it as such: “His Name (qua determinate Infinity) is True.” It is in this sense Guru Nanak says that all that God has created is His Name. -Copyright © Dr. Jasbir Singh Ahluwalia http://www.sikhspectrum.com/052003/time_jasbir.htm[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

aanjan · 20 Aug 2006

"ੴ ਸਤਿ ਨਾਮੁ ਕਰਤਾ ਪੁਰਖੁ ਨਿਰਭਉ ਨਿਰਵੈਰੁ ਅਕਾਲ ਮੂਰਤਿ ਅਜੂਨੀ ਸੈਭੰ ਗੁਰ ਪ੍ਰਸਾਦਿ ॥ ੴ सति नामु करता पुरखु निरभउ निरवैरु अकाल मूरति अजूनी सैभं गुर प्रसादि ॥ ik-oNkaar sat naam kartaa purakh nirbha-o nirvair akaal moorat ajoonee saibhaN gur parsaad. One Universal Creator God. The Name Is Truth. Creative Being Personified. No Fear. No Hatred. Image Of The Undying, Beyond Birth, Self-Existent. By Guru's Grace ~" What makes you to translate "ik-oNkaar" to "One Universal " and "kartaa purakh" to Creator God?. You dont need to translate to know the meaning. That is what it means in lay man's language. Maybe Brahmins need translations. So go learn Gurmukhi.

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

aanjan · 22 Aug 2006

Mr Chandra Ji I dont see any mysterious reasons. Either you dont have a reply or you use filthy language those are the only 2 reasons.

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Harjas Kaur · 23 Aug 2006

Chandra, can you explain why you are attempting to subvert the obvious definition of monotheism present in Gurbani? As was explained above by Aanjan, it really needs no tricky definitions or clever mental words. The truth is obvious to anyone...except those with ulterior political motives. Sikh is Sikh, not Hindu. End of discussion, story, satsang. If you want to understand Sikhism...read Gurbani. If you want to understand definition of monotheism in Sikhism...read Gurbani. If you want to know anything at all...consult the Satguru...don't waste time talking to some foolish person like me. Gursikh bibian who sweep the gurudwara and feed the hungry with nourishing langar, and never speak about these things have more enlightenment than me. If you ask any Gursikh bibi about monothesim, she will wisely give you the answer... "Be silent in your ego and bow your head to Guruji's feet, and ask the Satguru to give you understanding. Then everything you need to know will be known." Clever thoughts kill the truth and egoistic utterances are lies that defile the speaker. The only plane I wish to be on is the plane where I touch the dust of the feet of the sadhsangat, not to have satsang with intellectuals or be puffed up with delusion of self-conceit. The truth is still the truth regardless of what anyone thinks about it. It was truth before I was born. It will be truth after I die. My opinion is irrelevent to the truth. Sangat ji please forgive my stupidity. Any wisdom that is here belongs to Guruji's words alone. ਸੁਣਿ ਸੁਣਿ ਗੰਢਣੁ ਗੰਢੀਐ ਲਿਖਿ ਪੜਿ ਬੁਝਹਿ ਭਾਰੁ ॥ सुणि सुणि गंढणु गंढीऐ लिखि पड़ि बुझहि भारु ॥ sun sun gandhan gandhee-ai likh parh bujheh bhaar. Again and again, we hear and tell stories; we read and write and understand loads of knowledge, ਤ੍ਰਿਸਨਾ ਅਹਿਨਿਸਿ ਅਗਲੀ ਹਉਮੈ ਰੋਗੁ ਵਿਕਾਰੁ ॥ त्रिसना अहिनिसि अगली हउमै रोगु विकारु ॥ tarisnaa ahinis aglee ha-umai rog vikaar. but still, desires increase day and night, and the disease of egotism fills us with corruption. ਓਹੁ ਵੇਪਰਵਾਹੁ ਅਤੋਲਵਾ ਗੁਰਮਤਿ ਕੀਮਤਿ ਸਾਰੁ ॥੨॥ ओहु वेपरवाहु अतोलवा गुरमति कीमति सारु ॥२॥ oh vayparvaahu atolvaa gurmat keemat saar. ||2|| That Carefree Lord cannot be appraised; His Real Value is known only through the Wisdom of the Guru's Teachings. ||2|| ਲਖ ਸਿਆਣਪ ਜੇ ਕਰੀ ਲਖ ਸਿਉ ਪ੍ਰੀਤਿ ਮਿਲਾਪੁ ॥ लख सिआणप जे करी लख सिउ प्रीति मिलापु ॥ lakh si-aanap jay karee lakh si-o pareet milaap. Even if someone has hundreds of thousands of clever mental tricks, and the love and company of hundreds of thousands of people - ਬਿਨੁ ਸੰਗਤਿ ਸਾਧ ਨ ਧ੍ਰਾਪੀਆ ਬਿਨੁ ਨਾਵੈ ਦੂਖ ਸੰਤਾਪੁ ॥ बिनु संगति साध न ध्रापीआ बिनु नावै दूख संतापु ॥ bin sangat saaDh na Dharaapee-aa bin naavai dookh santaap. still, without the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy, he will not feel satisfied. Without the Name, all suffer in sorrow. ਹਰਿ ਜਪਿ ਜੀਅਰੇ ਛੁਟੀਐ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਚੀਨੈ ਆਪੁ ॥੩॥ हरि जपि जीअरे छुटीऐ गुरमुखि चीनै आपु ॥३॥ har jap jee-aray chhutee-ai gurmukh cheenai aap. ||3|| Chanting the Name of the Lord, O my soul, you shall be emancipated; as Gurmukh, you shall come to understand your own self. ||3|| -SGGS P. 20 [%sig%]

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

aanjan · 24 Aug 2006

That was the problem hindu brahmins had with Sikh Guru Sahibaan all the time. As Sikh Guru Sahibaan talked the laymans language the Brahmin class was at total unease as they lost their business of translation. And you know what; whatever translations you make from gurmukhi you are bound to miss / add something and the translations DONOT have the 'paras kala' of Gurbani. So do learn gurmukhi and speak the laymans language. As Guru Nanak SAhib himself says [gurbani] nw hau jqI sqI nhI piVAw mUrK mugDw jnmu BieAw ][/gurbani] and Guru Ram Daas Sahib says that he does not do what the Hindoos do [gurbani] gauVI guAwryrI mhlw 4 cauQw caupdy <> siqgur pRswid ] pMifqu swsq isimRiq piVAw ] jogI gorKu gorKu kirAw ] mY mUrK hir hir jpu piVAw ]1] nw jwnw ikAw giq rwm hmwrI ] hir Bju mn myry qru Baujlu qU qwrI ]1] rhwau ] sMinAwsI ibBUq lwie dyh svwrI ] pr iqRA iqAwgu krI bRhmcwrI ] mY mUrK hir Aws qumwrI ]2] KqRI krm kry sUrqxu pwvY ] sUdu vYsu pr ikriq kmwvY ] mY mUrK hir nwmu CfwvY ]3] sB qyrI isRsit qUM Awip rihAw smweI ] gurmuiK nwnk dy vifAweI ] mY AMDuly hir tyk itkweI ]4]1]39][/gurbani] So you dont need to be clever to figure out what the Sikh Gurus have said but need prem and bhau to be on the sikhi marg and stay nirbhau of everything else (including bhoots/devis/devtas).

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

aanjan · 25 Aug 2006

send it @gmail.com

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

aanjan · 28 Aug 2006

no its aanjaan

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

Gutenberg · 31 Aug 2006

Dear, it was the opposite way round. Kabir allways came first.

Re: Allah and Hindoo Gods in Gurbani

lucky411 · 03 Sep 2006

guru granth sahib refers to god in many names, such as waheguru ram allah