Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gursikhs and Bana

Gursikhs and Bana

_lowest_ · 10 Aug 2006

waheguru jee ka khalsa, waheguru jee kee fateh firstly i have sooo much respect for those gursikhs who wear guru jees bana. seeing someone wearing bana makes my day. it's an inspiration. i have been wondering about wearing bana with/without a pajama. many singhs wear a bana without pajama, and i always see singhni's with a pajama. im just wondering why. is it because of culture? theres no difference between the legs of a man and a woman. how is it supposed to be? was bana originally worn with or without a pajama? please forgive me if i have caused any offence or if this topic has already been discussed. if so could someone please provide me with the link? thankyou! waheguru jee ka khalsa, waheguru jee kee fateh!! [%sig%]

Re: Gursikhs and Bana

Tee · 10 Aug 2006

Vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh Khalsa jee, Although both singhs and singhnia have equal status in sikhi, they both have a different physical form. It is acceptable for singhs to show their legs, just as it was acceptable for singhs to wrestle in maharajs time, with just their kachere on. However this would be completly unacceptable for singhnia to do so. Singhnia should wear pyjami when wearing bana. Vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Gursikhs and Bana

Garjkaur · 10 Aug 2006

I don't agree with Tee. It is perfectly fine for a Singhnee to wear bana without a pajamee. The kashera is down to the knees and tight covering everything properly. I think it is just a cultural thing and therefore Singhnees prefer to wear it rather than get scolded by people. Singhnees do not wear pajamee when doing punj pyare dee seva.

Re: Gursikhs and Bana

Gurparsad · 10 Aug 2006

i personally am totally in favour of equal seva rights for women, i.e. punj pyaaria di seva, kirtan seva at harmandar sahib etc. but i believe that in western culture womens' legs have been sexualized - it's a 'turn on' for men when they see bare legs of woman. however this is not the case for men. not many women would say seeing men's legs makes them feel kaami. it's the same priniciple as to why a man can show his chest but a woman must keep covered. in the end though, it's each individual's choice. i personally would not want to give anyone kaami thoughs in a darbar by showing my legs.

Re: Gursikhs and Bana

_lowest_ · 12 Aug 2006

waheguru jee ka khalsa, waheguru jee kee fateh! thankyou for your replies. i just have one last question was the bana originally worn with or without a pajama? waheguru jee ka khalsa, waheguru jee kee fateh!

Re: Gursikhs and Bana

baba amarjeet singh · 12 Aug 2006

no garjkaur im afarid you are quite rong tee has got it spot on. bibiaa should wear pyjama. is this not blatantly obvious? why cant you take tht women and men are different? did you not go to school? women and men are different, they have diferent roles, there are things which men can/should do and things tht women can/should do. women should not expose their legs. which gurmukh singhnia in the past have done this? please a benti to the singhnia. stop trying to be singhs. [%sig%]

Re: Gursikhs and Bana

ONE · 12 Aug 2006

waheguru jee ka khalsa, waheguru jee kee fateh!! Here is an interesting watercolour from the Collection of the British Museum It can be seen that the Singh wears a Dumalla with Shasters and a small/short Kurta/Chola or it could be a Loi (Shawl) The Singhni appears to be wearing a 'Keski' or some sort of Headcovering under her Shawl - She is wearing a Ghagra (gathered skirt) Those who have elderly grandparents will know that rural punjabi women tended to wear Ghagra - The women in my family only started wearing salwars in the late 1960s - they tended to wear very heavy gathered Ghagras. Interesting note Neither the Singh nor Singhni are wearing Pajamas. [IMG]http://img235.imageshack.us/img235/1700/pajamaik4.jpg[/IMG] Hope you enjoyed the picture ! GurFateh ! Ranjit Singh 'Freed' [%sig%]

Re: Gursikhs and Bana

E · 13 Aug 2006

interesting you can see dress codes for singhs and singhnis are DIFFERENT from the picture. firstly you can see the singh is showing much more leg, where as the singhni is wearing a dress basically down to her ankles secondly the singhni is wearing a keski with a shawl/chunni on top - ( NOT a 3 foot dummalla) thirdly the singhni is wearing a red top, not blue (which is the colour tapoban recommend) so one must question the reliability of the source.

Re: Gursikhs and Bana

Garjkaur · 13 Aug 2006

Gurparsad jee, what part of a women's body hasn't been sexualized in Western society? Neck, lips, you name it. Does this mean that Gursikh bibiya should wear a burka? In my opinion any part of the body can make someone kaami. The key as I have been taught by older Gursikhs is to remain saavdaan and not let yourself or another be vulnerable to this. Veer Amarjeet Singh jee, I do understand that men and women are different physically and yes I go to school. Everyone is entitled to their opinion though right? [%sig%]

Re: Gursikhs and Bana

----^^^^---- · 14 Aug 2006

take it easy amarjeet singh. singhnees are not required to wear pajami. its their choice or say a cultural thing but not a gurmat thing. guru sahib doesn't care if a singhnee does no wear a pajami.

Re: Gursikhs and Bana

E · 16 Aug 2006

interesting theory, have you got any evidence, ie from bhai sahibs books, if so could i have page references. garjkaur are you saying a women can respectfully show as much of her body as a man? is it all about sexuality or does respect play a role in dress? as far as i have gathered bibia in akj have always worn pajame, so obviously it is very acceptable for singhnis to wear pajame aswell as keski and chunni, because bhai sahibs wife did along with all other puratan singhnees from then up until now.

Re: Gursikhs and Bana

baba amarjeet singh · 16 Aug 2006

singhnees are required to wear pyjamai. it is a gurmat thing. guru sahib does care about gurmat [%sig%]