Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

DutchiSikh · 09 Aug 2006

Im reading the book A History of The Sikh by Khushwant Singh and I get the feeling that the Sikhs were strong enough to kick the British out of India. Why didn't Ranjeet Singh followed the advice of the Sikh generals to finish with the British once and for all? Altough some other books wrote that the Sikhs were indeed afraid of the British so that they keep quiet. But is this true? The Singhs almost defeated the British in 1849 while the most of them were fighting among themselves. What a great change did we missed. What if the Sikhs had kicked the British out of India? Probably we would rull over Delhi and most the Hindustan of today would be ruled by Khalsa. What is the sangats view on this topic? [%sig%] Post Edited (08-09-06 11:27)

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

Kulbir Singh · 09 Aug 2006

I have thought about this many times and I truly believe that when the British were engaged in fighting the Marathas in 1820 or so, Sikhs should have attacked the British divided Hindustan between Marathas and Sikhs. Reading history, I have a feeling that Raja Ranjit Singh did have a complex when dealing with the British. The treaty that he signed with British restricted him to Sutlej. This was totally wrong on his part to have given away the land up to Delhi to him. The land up to Delhi was governed by Sikhs of Phulkian kingdoms and if anything this land should been under Sarkar-e-Khalsa. We needed someone like Hari Singh Nalwa to lead us. Sikh nation would have been the foremost in the world. [%sig%]

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

DutchiSikh · 09 Aug 2006

++ I have thought about this many times and I truly believe that when the British were engaged in fighting the Marathas in 1820 or so, Sikhs should have attacked the British divided Hindustan between Marathas and Sikhs. ++ Didn't the British completly finished the Marathas off in the battle of Panipat? How strong were the Marathas in 1820? ++Reading history, I have a feeling that Raja Ranjit Singh did have a complex when dealing with the British. The treaty that he signed with British restricted him to Sutlej. This was totally wrong on his part to have given away the land up to Delhi to him. The land up to Delhi was governed by Sikhs of Phulkian kingdoms and if anything this land should been under Sarkar-e-Khalsa.++ I think that Ranjeet Singh fixed his eye(s) to much on the Afghan border. He didn't payed that much attention to the British. Or was it fear? Khushwant Singh notes that Ranjeet said something like this: "Did you forgot what the British did against the Marathas?" If this quote is true then Ranjeet Singh was falling from the Khalsa spirit. Anyway, the Sikhs paid in my opinion to much of this big mistake. Khalsa didn't lost their country but also much of their spirit. Look the to map of Punjab under the Khalsa in 1839 and see what it's left of Punjab today. ++We needed someone like Hari Singh Nalwa to lead us. Sikh nation would have been the foremost in the world. ++ Khushwant Singh is somehow quoting strange things about the great general. According to him Sardar Nalwa was an agressor against the Afghan folk and he plundered many villages.

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

S Singh · 09 Aug 2006

Maybe Raja Ranjit Singh should not have been so aggressive with the Phulkiya Sardars pre 1809 before the treaty with the British was signed. His aggression scared the Phulkian Sardars into the arms of the British. Whenever Raja Ranjit Singh crossed the Satluj he began acting like a hungry wolf amongst sheeps. At little bit of diplomacy would have worked far better and Khalsa Rule could have extended all the way to the Jamuna river instead of the Satluj river. A united Punjab would have been stronger both militarily and economically in opposing British India.

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

Dalbir · 09 Aug 2006

I think that Ranjeet Singh fixed his eye(s) to much on the Afghan border. He didn't payed that much attention to the British. Or was it fear? Khushwant Singh notes that Ranjeet said something like this: "Did you forgot what the British did against the Marathas?" If this quote is true then Ranjeet Singh was falling from the Khalsa spirit. ----------------------------------------------- I don't think the maharaja was a religious man at all. He wasn't a strict Sikh by any stretch of the imagination despite the fact he kept his kesh and probably took amrit and even listened to bani regularly. I don't believe this myself but I remember my mother saying she believed that the Sikh raj flopped because of his excessive kam.

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

Seeker of the Truth · 09 Aug 2006

I heard Maharaja Ranjit Singh was an alcoholic and did a lot of anti-Sikhi things like worship idols and eat halal meat. Is this true?

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

Dalbir · 10 Aug 2006

I think he was alcoholic in the sense that he enjoyed a drink up like lots of Panjabis still do. Bhang taking was also common in those times with the gentry but I'm not sure if Ranjit did it. Yes he would worship with everyone (muslim and hindu) and used Brahmins quite a bit, especially in later life. Plus he had multiple wives, randy sod!

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

S Singh · 10 Aug 2006

Vijay Deep Singh wrote: >Bow to trinty of manifestation of Akal,Gurubar Akal,Guru Sabad and Guru >Panth. What is the 'trinty' of manifestation of Akal?

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

A Singh · 10 Aug 2006

DutchiSikh Ji, Kushwant Singh's writings on Sikh history are controvercial. The fact of multiple wives is true. This has been highlighted by Patwant Singh's book 'The Sikhs'. [%sig%]

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

Purana_sardar · 12 Aug 2006

Hmmm... interesting question you got yourself there. Since you framed it as a question, i will answer it... Ranjit Singh never attacked the british because he was their close ally for a long time. Despite being the greatest sikh king, (a north indian salaudin) the maharaja made the cardinal error of palling up with the brits. It was the smart bet in his time, as Gajpat Of Jind, the Patialas and the faridkots along with a host of other principalities used to play the darbari game with the brits. Strangely enough he also facilitated the peace pact between Marathas and the Brits. Ranjit Singh was a great man, of that there is no doubt but he was no saint. He had lots of concubines and one of them Moran is quite famous. He took nasha, he manipulated people but he single handedly did more for the sikh kaum than any other sikh in history after Banda Bahadur. The british eventually killed him, and to a large extent it was his own doing. But he also did many great things, like conquering Afghani kindoms of Peshawar, Kashmir and Waziristan (no other race has done so) and most importantly he provided peace and prosperity to all his citizens no matter their religious affiliations. Hari SIngh Nalwa was a great general but he was a useless administrator killing off bundles of people whenever he was made governer. But one thing to note here is : That this great man with the help of his clan defeated the mohammadens a feat which till today still has not been done twice even in todays age of nuclear weapons, maybe Mr. Bush can learn something from the rustic sikhs on how to combat what he calls terror. [%sig%]

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

Dalbir · 12 Aug 2006

Purana Sardar Ji, you said: .....maybe Mr. Bush can learn something from the rustic sikhs on how to combat what he calls terror. -------------------------- In my humble opinion the west has been quite instrumental, both historically and in modern times in bolstering Islamic Fundamentalists whilst it served their own purposes. Even in Maharaja Ranjit Singhs time the British would secretly stir religious trouble between Sikhs and the Muslims of Afghanistan whilst professing frienship with the darbar. This tacit support policy was again followed recently by the west (i.e. the Mujahadeen against the Russians) until it metamorphed to blow up in their faces. The biggest mistake Sikhs made was trusting the British. It cost them a kingdom and turned them into storm troopers for a cause that was not their own. The short term gain of some Sikhs in terms of employment and land, cost dearly in terms of sovereignity. Plus they have never been truly grateful. If we watch the dramas made regarding the World Wars, apart from the odd exceptions (like The English Patient), you would never know that Sikhs contributed to them! I personally see a lot of the problems Sikhs have faced in recent times as a direct result of the disarming and taming of the Khalsa by the British. That is the real reason we have suffered as a community with partition and 1984 etc. They made the swords of the Khalsa blunt, literally and figuratively. By the way I think you have misunderstood Nalwa, he was dealing with lawless bigots, hence his vigor but yes, burning down whole villages that supported these people was harsh but the common order of the day sadly. One positive about Ranjit Singh was that he done away with death penalties, for crimes, which I think may have been a first, so he wasn't all bad.

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

DutchiSikh · 13 Aug 2006

+++Ranjit Singh was a great man, of that there is no doubt but he was no saint. He had lots of concubines and one of them Moran is quite famous. He took nasha, he manipulated people but he single handedly did more for the sikh kaum than any other sikh in history after Banda Bahadur. The british eventually killed him, and to a large extent it was his own doing. But he also did many great things, like conquering Afghani kindoms of Peshawar, Kashmir and Waziristan (no other race has done so) and most importantly he provided peace and prosperity to all his citizens no matter their religious affiliations.++++ Do you reall think that Ranjit Singh was poisoned by the British?

Re: Why didn't Ranjeet Singh attacked the British?

JSGyani · 14 Aug 2006

Maharaja Ranjit Singh REVERSED the West to EAST INVASIONS through the Khaibar Pass that were happening from 2000BC...Aryan Invasion...to Muslim Invasions ... The MAHARAJA WENT UP RIVER and INVADED KABUL.. That is an achievement worthy of greatness...if any !! Reversing a trend nearly 3000 yeras old... [%sig%]