Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Will Gurdwara Reform Movement click?

Will Gurdwara Reform Movement click?

Singh · 08 Aug 2006

Will Gurdwara Reform Movement click? K. S. Chawla Ludhiana, August 8 When Mr Parkash Singh Badal and Jathedar Gurcharan Singh Tohra fell out in December, 1998, the events happened so quickly that Jathedar Tohra was eased out of the SGPC. Mr Badal humbled him with vengeance and chose not to accept his resignation but to out-vote him. Subsequently the cohorts of Mr Badal unleashed a vilification campaign against Jathedar Tohra and tried their level-best to bring out the malpractices that were rampant in the SGPC. Bibi Jagir Kaur, who succeeded Jathedar Tohra, even went to the extent of declaring that a white paper would be issued against Jathedar Tohra, but nothing came out of this campaign. Despite the fact that Jathedar Tohra could not get a single seat in the last Punjab Vidhan Sabha elections, he was able to maintain his image and relevance in the Sikh affairs. Finally with the turn of events, Mr Badal and Jathedar Tohra patched up. It was during the period of discord between the two stalwarts that a demand was raised by the Badal camp for gurdwara reforms. After the death of Jathedar Tohra, Mr Badal came to have absolute control over the SGPC affairs and things began to drift. The SGPC began to be used as power of patronage and the resources were diverted for the political activities. Moreover, the establishment also began to use political pressure to further their prospects. The ousting of Mr Manjit Singh Calcutta from the SGPC scene came as the last stroke which blurred the Sikh and traditional face of the great institution. Now when the things are in the open, the splinter Akali groups are joining hands to beat Mr Badal with the holy stick. They call it Gurdwara Reform Movement - II. The situation got aggravated with the incidents of July 2 at Amritsar on the occasion of celebrations in connection with the quadri-centenary of the establishment of Akal Takht when Badal supporters led by Mr Avtar Singh Makkar and supporters of Mr Simranjit Singh Mann came to blows on the stage. The Jathedars of the Takhts on their own chose to single out Mr Simranjit Singh Mann and his group for the unsavoury situation and went to the extent of asking them to atone for their conduct by offering prayers at Fatehgarh Sahib. Mr Simranjit Singh Mann decided to invite all the splinter groups, including Mr Manjit Singh Calcutta, to launch the Gurdwara Reform Movement and gave the slogan of freeing gurdwaras from the stranglehold of Mr Badal. The pertinent question is: ‘Will the new initiative get a response from the Sikhs? While the average Sikh knows that the gurdwara administration has numerous ailments, the SGPC members on their own are becoming an authority over the gurdwaras falling in their constituencies and some other questionable practices have crept into the administration. But what is needed is a critical appraisal on the part of those who claim to have launched the gurdwara reforms clearly defining what ails the SGPC. They will also have to educate the Sikh Sangat regarding the affairs of the SGPC. Those who have announced to launch the Gurdwara Reform Movement should know that the people in general and the Sikhs in particular know that the elections to the Punjab Vidhan Sabha are due to be held within a period of six months and their exercise should not remain confined to playing politics and they must show their sincerity to the purpose.

Re: Will Gurdwara Reform Movement click?

JSGyani · 09 Aug 2006

how can this motley crew click ?? they are out for badals blood only..NOT genuine SIKHI !! See how many of them attain their spiritual benefit from taksalis and babas... imho..these are just another group of "mahants" who want to drive out the present Badalee Mahants...Genuine Gurmatt is far away from BOTH [%sig%]

Re: Will Gurdwara Reform Movement click?

Prabhjoyt Singh · 12 Aug 2006

who are you talking about Jarnial Singh arshi? [%sig%]

Re: Will Gurdwara Reform Movement click?

Purana_sardar · 12 Aug 2006

kudos to mr. arshi.... you hit the nail on the head... Mr mann is a decent man of that there is no doubt but the hate for badal overides the panthic dal. They are blinded... the Amritsar episode brought shame on our community and yet none of the jathedars have banned the use of the mike in the presence of the granth sahib for any other reason than reading gurbani. Why the hell should any person be it badal or mann speak to a sangat on their own accord when the granth sahib is present. This was the reason they had the spat in the first place. Unless we reform, sikhi will be taken over by radhswamis, sucha saudhas and maybe nirankaris (the worst kind). Sant Jarnail Singh must be a tortured soul seeing things like this happening [%sig%]

Re: Will Gurdwara Reform Movement click?

JSGyani · 13 Aug 2006

Precisely my point. Any VOICE from AKAL TAKHAT has to be the VOICE of AKAAL...GURBANI of Sri Guru Garnth Sahib Jee ONLY. This is the THRONE of AKAAL..and TODAY this Voice is represented by Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee ONLY. What right has mere human ( a PAID granthi ) to say that what he says is "HUKM of AKAAL".... Was the Voice of RURR SINGH..voice of Akaal when he siropaed general Odwyer ? He was also in the very same post Vedanti is occupying now ?? IF Rurr Singh was an agent of the British..so is Vedanti an agent of the RSS/Badal etc..whats the difference..? Why are Sikhs so emasculated that they regard the "squeak" of an agent..as the VOICE of AKAAl and DISREGARD SGGS ??? The SGGS is made to be a SILENT OBSERVER !!! After Sahib Sri guru Hargobind JI...LEFT Amritsar..NO other GURU ever returned to Akal takhat.... so are we to beleive that the VOICE of AKAAL was silent throughout the Guru Har rai - Guru Gobind Singh Ji period ?? This si not to deny the power and sattus of Akal Takhat..it is to make clear that the Voice of Akaal is in the SGGS...and our Eteranal Living GURU takes PRECEDENCE over any human where ever he may be..even on the AT building...especially so in the case of spineless vedanti..who has proved himself a bigger chamcha of RSS Badal than Zail singh ever was of Indira Gandhi. How can any self respecting SINGH take a mike and SHOUT in the Guru Jis presence ?? The MIKE should only carry the ILAHI GURBANI...our Living GURU.( not silent spectator). Prabhjyot Singh Ji..this has nothign whatsoever to do with Khalistan....i want it even more than you...but removing DASTAARS and wahcking the living daylights out of other Singhs is NOT khalistan....how could that be ?? Is Khalsitan going to be like that ?? [%sig%]

Re: Will Gurdwara Reform Movement click?

Kulbir Singh · 14 Aug 2006

Movement will click. Just bring Dharmi people on the forefront. If a movement is led by tyaar bar tyaar Khalsa, it will get the support of people. Otherwise not. [%sig%]

Re: Will Gurdwara Reform Movement click?

niyarakhalsa -a complete idiot · 19 Aug 2006

just a wild thought ... 1800-1850 sikh raaj ...indulgence in money .... influx of power greedy into sikhi... 1850-1900 british control ... degradtion of sikhi values... Begining of a New era : step 1 : scholars .... vir singh , khan singh nabha , sahib singh singh sabha & gurdwara sudhar lehir ...we wrest the contol of gurdwaras but are still under extreme influence of biparwad... step2 : emeergence of Sikh rehit maryada ... to stop biparwad & mahant wad; emergencee of of jatha - widespread parchar of keertan and bani ...but side by side emergence of magical babas ; fake ssants;radhaswamis ; naamdharis ;satnaamis; manmat ; current times- sikhi everywhre in the world - gore sikhs ; uk sikhs ; black sikhs ; sikhi will rise and overthrow wild beasts who are in power ( may not be this movement - but this could be part 3 in our story ) ... so we can see t his current movemet not as a solution of all ills but rather a a small step in the whole awakening ... Al ot has yet to be done .... ( one problem I see with this movement is that they useing taksal as one of it major source of stenth ; but we know that the current taksal is just beahaving like any other sadh dera - fighting over property ; money ; power ... ) may be our next movemnt will be bsed solely on the power of gurmat and gurbani ... so all of on this forum ...lets stop chating and indulge more into naam and bani ...uplift our jeevans and be the soldiers for the next movement !!! [%sig%]

Re: Will Gurdwara Reform Movement click?

confused · 20 Aug 2006

to be honest sikhi is sort of on the rise but i dont see strength in it...when i read puraatan saakhis or stories from bhai randhir singhs days i dont see that same sikhi soo i dont see anything in sight for it right now