dhil in the shower
raj karega khalsa · 02 Aug 2006
Vaahiguroo Jee Kaa Khaalsaa Vaahiguroo Jee Kee Fathe!!
Khaalsaa Jee, recently, ive been hearing about/seeing a lot of gursikhs wearing steel, sheathless kirpaans on string gathray while doing ishnaan.
Is this practise ok, according to gurmat rehat maryada?
I'm not sure why, but i've always believed that your kirpaan should b in a sheath and on a proper gatra. I don't know why i believe this, I just do.
Im really confused, so could u plz explain this to me. Am i wrong or wut?
Bhul Chuk Maph Karnee
Vaahiguroo Jee Kaa Khaalsaa Vaahiguroo Jee Kee Fathe!!
Re: dhil in the shower
amarjeet singh · 02 Aug 2006
ur 1ft sarbloh kirpaan, should remain on ur body at all times wrap it round ur keski durin ishnaan
Re: dhil in the shower
raj karega khalsa · 07 Aug 2006
so wen we see gursikhs doing this, wut should we say, how should we approach it?
Re: dhil in the shower
Balpreet Singh · 08 Aug 2006
I think that a kirpan should be in a miaan and in a gatra. There can be some very special circumstances perhaps where an exception might be ok (the example given by gupt), but ishnan doesnt' qualify. I don't think a kirpaan on a string is easier to tie around the dastaar.
If you see someone you know who is wearing a kirpan on a string, very gently approach the subject. We are all just humans and we still have egos. So if someone tells us something even if it's absolutely right, we feel offended and get defensive if it's not said in the right way.
Re: dhil in the shower
Balpreet Singh · 08 Aug 2006
A kirpan on a string is not a real kirpan. A real kirpan [i]requires[/i] a miaan. It's sharp and would cut you otherwise. The string kirpans are just models.
There is no legitimate reason not to have a kirpan on a gatra in a miaan when doing ishnaan.