Idol worship and Sikhism
anjaan · 28 Jul 2006
[gurbani] pwQru ly pUjih mugD gvwr ] Eih jw Awip fuby qum khw qrxhwru ]2] [/gurbani]
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
anjaan · 28 Jul 2006
[gurbani] pwQru ly pUjih mugD gvwr ] Eih jw Awip fuby qum khw qrxhwru ]2] [/gurbani]anjaan · 30 Jul 2006
Did you find what chandra means in punjabi? And if I translate it to punjabi people would be laughing at you my friend. That is the reason I put Gurmukhi as in Guru Sahib. So I wait for your reply on stone worship. Narad told his followers to worship stones so hindus worship stones. May be narad made a fool of his followers (Hindus)??? [gurbani]ihMdU mUly BUly[/gurbani] The word moolay means that they are wrong from the roots. the are on entirely wrong path It doesnot mean they knew earlier dont be so niave by saying "It means they knew it earlier now they have forgotten" The statement says that they are on the wrong path and they are the blindest of the blind. So I wait for your reply on stone worship???anjaan · 31 Jul 2006
***** "Did you find what chandra means in punjabi? And if I translate it to punjabi people would be laughing at you my friend." How does that matter?. ***** You would know that if you look up what chandra means in punjabi ******* ਮਨ ਚੂਰੇ ਖਟੁ ਦਰਸਨ ਜਾਣੁ ॥ To conquer the mind is the knowledge of the six Shaastras. ******** What do you make out of this? Is Guru Sahib refering to the Shastras or is Guru Sahib saying that when you ਚੂਰ ਚੂਰ your ਮਨ it is equivalent to gaining the knowledge of Six Shaastras?? chandra******** So, Idol worship is for mind control (Chitta nirodha) and concentration. Idol worship is a method for concentration of mind. The mind want to move externally. It must be checked and turned within. Its habit is to dwell on names and forms, for all external ogjects posses names and forms. Such names and forms are made symbolic mental conceptions in order to divert mind from extrnal objects and make it dwell within itself. The idols, mantras, yantars are all meant to give food to the mind in its introvert state, so that it may later become capable of being concentrated, after which the superb state is reached. ******* Minds habit is to dwell on names and forms. Thats why Idol worship does not take you anywhere as the mind dwells on the stone rather than the formless. Do you do pathar puja?anjaan · 31 Jul 2006
******** नारदु ध्रू प्रहलादु सुदामा पुब भगत हरि के जु गणं ॥ Naarad, Dhroo, Prahlaad and Sudaamaa are accounted among the Lord's devotees of the past. ******** Qoute in parts when it suits you why dont YOU qoute in full [gurbani]nwrdu DR¨ pRhlwdu sudwmw pub Bgq hir ky ju gxM ][/gurbani] [gurbani]AMbrIku jXdyv iqRlocnu nwmw Avru kbIru BxM ][/gurbani] [gurbani]iqn kO Avqwru BXau kil iBMqir jsu jgqR pir CwieXau ][/gurbani] [gurbani]sRI gur rwmdws jXo jX jg mih qY hir prm pdu pwieXau ]3][/gurbani] Here Bhatt Ji is making a comparision and is not accepting AUTHORITY of Narad in anyway. He is saying that in the past they were counted as devotees. Note [gurbani]jXo jX jg mih [/gurbani] before Guru Raamdaas Sahib.anjaan · 31 Jul 2006
[gurbani]nwrid kihAw is pUj krWhI ] AMDy guMgy AMD AMDwru ][/gurbani] So do you agree that the Hindus are blind?anjaan · 31 Jul 2006
You talk about stature of Narad but forget that the pathar puja prescribed by Narad has been classified as useless by Guru Sahib what is your comment on that or are you a person who just takes parts of gurbani which suit you?anjaan · 31 Jul 2006
[gurbani] nwrd munI AKwieMdw Awgm jwnx DIrj AwxY] sux sux mslq mjlsY kr kr cuglI AwK vKwxY][/gurbani]anjaan · 31 Jul 2006
**** So your interpretation is not in line with the main stream sikh intrepretation. **** Learn punjabi then find the meaning of word [gurbani]mUly [/gurbani] English translations are still being worked on and are in no-way final. Its same as someone translating Chandra to punjabi. Do you get the point now?Kulbir Singh · 31 Jul 2006
------------- Could you please tell me which incident Guruji having in his mind when he says?: ਨਾਰਦਿ ਕਹਿਆ ਸਿ ਪੂਜ ਕਰਾਂਹੀ ॥ As Naarad instructed them, they are worshipping idols. Please don't ignore it? --------------- In life of most bhagats there is a period before they become bhagats and after. There is no doubt that Narad did get paramgat later on when he realized the true Guru but his period before meeting the true Guru is not according to Gurmat. Making the observation of Hindus of Guru Sahib’s time, Guru Sahib is saying that they are indulged in pathar-pooja and claim that these instructions are coming from Narad. Chandra Singh, one thing is for sure. Pathar pooja is not according to Gurmat and Sikhs consistently don't worship Vaheguru through any other means but Shabad. If Hindus want to do Moorti pooja, we have no problem with it. Just don't justify moorti pooja through Gurbani. Kulbir Singhmoorakh · 01 Aug 2006
I have a question for Chandra veerjee, and this is because of my limited knowledge on Hinduism. Chandra jee, isn't it true that Hinduism has adapted itself to the teachings of an avtaar and changed every single time an avtar came? I mean, in ancient times, meat was allowed, but after the coming of Buddha, the Hindus quit meat. Similarly, don't you think that the Hindus quit idol worship and in some cases even the caste system only after the Gurus came?anjaan · 01 Aug 2006
****** But the Hindu scriptures says the same thing. I have already quoted Sri Tulsidas so many times Nahi Kali Karam Na dharam Viveku, Ram Nam Avlamban Eku|| ******* In some other post you were saying it was charity now tulsi das says it naam. Can you decide what it is? Is it naam or daan?anjaan · 01 Aug 2006
****** "What do you make out of this? Is Guru Sahib refering to the Shastras or is Guru Sahib saying that when you ਚੂਰ ਚੂਰ your ਮਨ it is equivalent to gaining the knowledge of Six Shaastras??" He is saying that if you have conqured your mind, six Shaastras are of no use to you. But till then one needs the knowledge in them. ******** "But till then one needs the knowledge in them." Does guru sahib say that?anjaan · 01 Aug 2006
***** "Do you do pathar puja?" Yes i do all the time. ******* SO you are blind as per Guru Sahib ****** ਭਗਤ ਹੇਤਿ ਮਾਰਿਓ ਹਰਨਾਖਸੁ ਨਰਸਿੰਘ ਰੂਪ ਹੋਇ ਦੇਹ ਧਰਿਓ ॥ Where did he come from?. STONE ******* Does Guru Sahib say that?anjaan · 01 Aug 2006
[gurbani] r`b qoN iv`CuVI hoeI lukweI ƒ ku`qy vWg Kwx dw hlk ku`idAw rihMdw hY qy v`FI Awidk hrwm cIz ies dw mn-BwauNdw Kwxw ho jWdw hY (ijvyN ku`qy dw mn-BwauNdw Kwxw murdwr hY); (ieh lukweI) sdw JUT boldI hY, (mwno, murdwr KWdy ku`qy vWg) BauNk rhI hY, (ies qrHW ies dy AMdroN) Drm (dI AMs) qy (r`b dy guxW dI) ivcwr mu`k jWdI hY; ijqnw icr Ajyhy lok (jgq ivc) jIauNdy hn iehnW dI (koeI bMdw) ie`zq nhIN (krdw), jdoN mr jWdy hn, (lok iehnW ƒ) BYiVEN Xwd krdy hn [/gurbani] Now tell me if the idol worshipers are blind or not according to guru sahib?anjaan · 02 Aug 2006
***** "Now tell me if the idol worshipers are blind or not according to guru sahib?" Did you find about yourself being dog according to Guru Sahib?. What does http://www.gurugranthdarpan.com commentry says about pangati quoted by me?. ***** I posted it for you to read or do you just follow english translations which translate mool and moolay to primal lord?aanjan · 03 Aug 2006
Deeper meanings eh!!! Were you not the one talking deeper meanings? Or only when it suits you??? Is that the knowledge you are trying to teach here which you gained out of stone worship??? In another post you conveniently brushed aside an argument by refuting what your other fellow hindus had done in comparing some hindu text to the bible that it was totally wrong and was just made to make to fit to westerners. Maybe they are lesser hindus than you. Possibly even more blinder. Atleast I have not tried to fit it to the bible. And when I said that English translations are still being worked on you came up with your ‘idiotic robotic responses from you spongy grey matter’ of the translations being khalistanised? Was Bhai Sahib Singh Khalistani? Eh!!! You say that I should convince the three sikh sites why don’t you do it as you are on a mission to teach sikhi (and show that its derived from some hindu mythology). Why don’t you do this good job as previously you said you are aware from where mool is derived and possibly you are Sanskrit pundit? Or possibly you will not bother cos it suits your argument. ********* "do you just follow english translations which translate mool and moolay to primal lord?" I posted it from three sikh websites and all says the same thing different from you. Go and convince them first before convincing me. *********** What a pathetic childish response Chandra. So is Allah the same as in Islam? Why not worship s*** over stone?aanjan · 03 Aug 2006
******** Re: Abrahmic religions and Indic Spiritual Systems Author: Chandra Singh Date: 07-27-06 12:00 "And which leg is remaining according to Ramayan?" "Jen Ken Bidhi Dinhe, Dan karai Kalyan" Charity practiced in any way conduces to ones well being. ********* ਤੀਨੌ ਜੁਗ ਤੀਨੌ ਦਿੜੇ ਕਲਿ ਕੇਵਲ ਨਾਮ ਅਧਾਰ ********** Daan Karai Kalyan? Naam Karai Kalyan? Atleast Sikh Teachings are consistent in saying that Naam Karai Kalyan!!!! Naam Karai Kalyan?aanjan · 03 Aug 2006
Naam karay Kalayan? Ke Daan karay Kalayan?Balpreet Singh · 03 Aug 2006
I'm thinking this is one of those threads that goes totally out of control because no one pays any attention to it except the two people who keep posting. This is a simple issue: idol worship is condemened in Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Guru Gobind Singh called himself "idol smasher" in Zafarnamah. Guru Granth Sahib has told us that one who worships idols will find his effort go to complete waste. Guru Granth Sahib is not an idol. Guru Sahib is the embodiment of all divine qualities. Guru Granth Sahib contains divine knowledge and if someone reads or listens, these qualities take hold in them. This is not possible when worshipping an idol. The idol cannot teach anything. I'm not sure what this thread is so long for?aanjan · 03 Aug 2006
****** "Why not worship s*** over stone?" Answer my question and then i will reply. I promise it. IS CREATION AND CREATOR ARE SAME IN THE LIGHT OF GURUBANI? OR IS IT ETERNALLY SEPEARTE AS PREACHED BY ABRAHAMIC CULTS. ******* I have answered it where you asked for it go see it there Kid Balpreet Singh Ji this thread is long as chandra likes to bring in issues rather than give straight replies and he considers english translations better than the ones done earlier. Also he suffers from verbal diarohea and like to label people and thinks he has superior understanding of gurbani which he learnt by worshiping stones and from online english translations I think you you have put very nicely about dashmesh pitta 'buut shikaan' but chandra likes to think that idol worshipers are doing the right thing.Balpreet Singh · 03 Aug 2006
[gurbani]mhlw 5 ] jo pwQr kau khqy dyv ] qw kI ibrQw hovY syv ] jo pwQr kI pWeI pwie ] iqs kI Gwl AjWeI jwie ]1] Twkuru hmrw sd bolµqw ] srb jIAw kau pRBu dwnu dyqw ]1] rhwau ] AMqir dyau n jwnY AMDu ] BRm kw moihAw pwvY PMDu ] n pwQru bolY nw ikCu dyie ] Pokt krm inhPl hY syv ]2] jy imrqk kau cMdnu cVwvY ] aus qy khhu kvn Pl pwvY ] jy imrqk kau ibstw mwih rulweI ] qW imrqk kw ikAw Git jweI ]3] khq kbIr hau khau pukwir ] smiJ dyKu swkq gwvwr ] dUjY Bwie bhuqu Gr gwly ] rwm Bgq hY sdw suKwly ]4]4]12] [/gurbani] Fifth Mehla: Those who call a stone their god their service is useless. Those who fall at the feet of a stone god - their work is wasted in vain. ||1|| My Lord and Master speaks forever. God gives His gifts to all living beings. ||1||Pause|| The Divine Lord is within the self, but the spiritually blind one does not know this. Deluded by doubt, he is caught in the noose. The stone does not speak; it does not give anything to anyone. Such religious rituals are useless; such service is fruitless. ||2|| If a corpse is anointed with sandalwood oil, what good does it do? If a corpse is rolled in manure, what does it lose from this? ||3|| Says Kabeer, I proclaim this out loud behold, and understand, you ignorant, faithless cynic. The love of duality has ruined countless homes. The Lord's devotees are forever in bliss. ||4||4||12|| >>>>>>>>>>> It is not a belief but indeed a "law" that what we read takes hold within us. If I read a book about accounting, I will learn the skill of accounting. If I read about law, I become a lawyer. Because Guru Granth Sahib contains all divine qualities, when I read or listen, these qualities take hold in me. When you worship a rock, which qualities are you taking in? Are you taking in the quality that Durga has black hair and red sari? Or that she is riding a tiger? Do you also start to ride tigers? Or how about Ganesh? Does that idol inspire you to become elephant-headed? Which quality are you taking? Guru Gobind Singh translated Chandi Chratar. It doesn't mention anywhere to worship idols so how is it relevant? It is a translation of Markande Puraan. Even in such translation such as Vaar Sri Bhagauti, Guru Sahib begins the translation with the clear statement that everything has been created by the one Akaal and all power was obtained from him and it is all his play. Salutation is given first and only to the Sikh Gurus. Please tell me where it says to worship idols? Hindus are free to worship in any way they see fit. But Idol worship is clearly condemened in Sikhism. This is a Sikh forum and Sikh ideals will be highlighted. If you don't like it, stick to Hindu Unity.aanjan · 03 Aug 2006
Those who worship stone are called blind arent they chandra?aanjan · 03 Aug 2006
**** "So is Allah the same as in Islam?" No. ***** that is the reason Why later translations replaced RAM, Govind, GuPAl, Hrshikesh, Brahmn, Parbrahmn etc with God? Cos ram is not the one who lost his wifeBalpreet Singh · 03 Aug 2006
Worshipping a Granth with no regard to the Shabad inside would be idol worship, no doubt. The fact that Guru Sahib is Shabad Guru in the form of a Granth is the difference. The Shabad is the Guru, encased in the Granth. True worship of Guru Granth Sahib is indeed reading and reflecting on the Shabad. If someone does not do this and is doing manmat while bowing to Guru Sahib then I will say very openly that this bowing is a waste. What does the idol contain? Rock. What can you learn from the rock? Please tell me. What do you learn from the idol? You asked me to quote from "other gurus" besides "Kabir". That shabad I quoted is from Guru Arjan Dev jee. Guru Gobind Singh says, “The idol worshipping hill men want to kill me, because they are idol - worshippers and I am an idol smasher” ( Zafarnamah, verse 95); As for your statement, "Vow!!. are you saying that Sikh gurus were copying from Hindu sources?" Not copying. Translating. Dasam Granth was not compiled by Guru Gobind Singh. It was compiled by Bhai Mani Singh. Dasam Granth contains translations of Hindu texts as well as Guru Sahib's bani like Jaap Sahib or Akal Ustat, etc. These translations are of Puraans and other Hindu texts. Guru Gobind Singh did not give any special place to Raam or Krishan but did translate their stories to make them available to the Sikhs. He says very clearly though that he never meditates or worships Kishan or Bishan or anyone else except the one Akal. [gurbani] goNf ] BYrau BUq sIqlw DwvY ] Kr bwhnu auhu Cwru aufwvY ]1] hau qau eyku rmeIAw lYhau ] Awn dyv bdlwvin dYhau ]1] rhwau ] isv isv krqy jo nru iDAwvY ] brd cFy faurU FmkwvY ]2] mhw mweI kI pUjw krY ] nr sY nwir hoie AauqrY ]3] qU khIAq hI Awid BvwnI ] mukiq kI brIAw khw CpwnI ]4] gurmiq rwm nwm ghu mIqw ] pRxvY nwmw ieau khY gIqw ]5]2]6] [/gurbani]Seeker of the Truth · 03 Aug 2006
Sikhs don't call Guru Granth Sahib Ji as their god, unlike those idol worshippers who worship stones as if it was their god.Angad Madan · 03 Aug 2006
Please don't insult Guru Sahib by saying that Sikhism "condemns" idol-worshippers and that Guru Sahib was an "idol-smasher." Firstly, if you remember, Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself did darshan at Naina Devi Mandir. This is a historical fact. Secondly, by condeming people as "idol-worshippers," you are talking like the same fanatical mullahs who oppressed the Sikhs and Hindus and called them kafirs. Sikhi is about tolerance taught in the Eastern faiths, not about the intolerance, hostility, and ignorance preached Muhammad and Islam. Also, if you see in Gurbani, 99% of all references to God are based on Hindu origins, like Parmaatma, Gopal, Ram, Har Har, Hari, etc.Balpreet Singh · 03 Aug 2006
Prove to me that Guru Gobind Singh went to Naina Devi. In Sikh history we have such heros like Bhai Bhairon at the time of Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee, who went to Naina Devi and cut off the idol's nose. The Hindus complained to Guru Sahib and Bhai Bhairon said "take me to the Devi". When he got there, he said, "let's leave everything and ask Devi Mata who has cut her nose." He then asked in a very polite voice who had cut her nose off. The stone was silent as always. Bhai Bhairon then said, "the goddess who cannot express herself, who can not ask for justice, who can not save herself, how such a helpless godess can give you any sort of relief or peace?" Guru Gobind Singh who called himself "but-shikkun" was an idol smasher. So I think the RSS type can stop with their stories of idol worship. Chandra Singh, Guru Gobind Singh translated Chandi Charitra and other texts because they were exclusive material for the Brahmins. This opened them up to the masses. There are many stories of courage and bravery in them. As for your quote: why do you rely on translations? I'm not sure how the translator has neglected to translate "sunayo"? No where does it say "I" have made these stories. It just said they were made. Even for a moment, for argument's sake lets say Guru Sahib made these stories (Chandi story is from Markanday Puraan), so what? Fictional stories to inspire courage. Where exactly does Guru Sahib say to worship this Devi?Seeker of the Truth · 03 Aug 2006
<<>> What makes you think I am a Khalistani? ------------------------------------------------------------------------- <<>> Guru Granth Sahib Ji (Page 1349): “If the Lord Allah lives only in the mosque, then to whom does the rest of the world belong? According to the Hindus, the Lord's Name abides in the idol, but there is no truth in either of these claims. || 1 || O Allah, O Raam, I live by Your Name. Please show mercy to me, O Master.” "I warred with the idol-worshipping hill chiefs, For, I am the breaker of idols and they their worshippers" - Guru Gobind Singh Ji (Zafarnama) Would it make you feel better if I label these people as "Hindus" instead of "Idol-worshippers"? [%sig%]Balpreet Singh · 03 Aug 2006
Chandra, Give up. The tuks you've supplied refer to Vahiguru. Bhagauti is not your Devi but Vahiguru, the eternal Akaal. Sikhs are not Hindus. Sikhs are against idol worshipping because it is a fruitless and rather stupid act. But no one is telling you that you are forbidden from doing this. You are free to worship Hanuman and Ganesha. If someone tries to forcibily stop you, you can rely on the Khalsa to protect you, but Idol worship is and forever will be unacceptable in Gurmat.Seeker of the Truth · 03 Aug 2006
Dasam Granth Sahib (Page 42): ਬਾਸ ਕੀਓ ਬਿਖਿਆਨ ਸੋ ਬੈਠ ਕੈ ਐਸੇ ਹੀ ਐਸੇ ਸੁ ਬੈਸ ਬਿਤਾਇਓ ॥ बास कीओ बिखिआन सो बैठ कै ऐसे ही ऐसे सु बैस बिताइओ ॥ He spends his life in such performing evil actions and wastes his life in such pursuits. ਸਾਚੁ ਕਹੋਂ ਸੁਨ ਲੇਹੁ ਸਭੈ ਜਿਨ ਪ੍ਰੇਮ ਕੀਓ ਤਿਨ ਹੀ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਪਾਇਓ ॥੯॥੨੯॥ साचु कहों सुन लेहु सभै जिन प्रेम कीओ तिन ही प्रभ पाइओ ॥९॥२९॥ I speak Truth, all should turn their ears towards it: he, who is absorbed in True Love, he would realize the Lord. 9.29. ਕਾਹੂ ਲੈ ਪਾਹਨ ਪੂਜ ਧਰਯੋ ਸਿਰ ਕਾਹੂ ਲੈ ਲਿੰਗ ਗਰੇ ਲਟਕਾਇਓ ॥ काहू लै पाहन पूज धरयो सिर काहू लै लिंग गरे लटकाइओ ॥ Someone worshipped stone and placed it on his head. Someone hung the phallus (lingam) from his neck. ਕਾਹੂ ਲਖਿਓ ਹਰਿ ਅਵਾਚੀ ਦਿਸਾ ਮਹਿ ਕਾਹੂ ਪਛਾਹ ਕੋ ਸੀਸੁ ਨਿਵਾਇਓ ॥ काहू लखिओ हरि अवाची दिसा महि काहू पछाह को सीसु निवाइओ ॥ Someone visualized God in the South and someone bowed his head towards the West. ਕੋਉ ਬੁਤਾਨ ਕੋ ਪੂਜਤ ਹੈ ਪਸੁ ਕੋਉ ਮ੍ਰਿਤਾਨ ਕੋ ਪੂਜਨ ਧਾਇਓ ॥ कोउ बुतान को पूजत है पसु कोउ म्रितान को पूजन धाइओ ॥ Some fool worships the idols and someone goes to worship the dead. ਕੂਰ ਕ੍ਰਿਆ ਉਰਝਿਓ ਸਭ ਹੀ ਜਗ ਸ੍ਰੀ ਭਗਵਾਨ ਕੋ ਭੇਦੁ ਨ ਪਾਇਓ ॥੧੦॥੩੦॥ कूर क्रिआ उरझिओ सभ ही जग स्री भगवान को भेदु न पाइओ ॥१०॥३०॥ The whole world is entangled in false rituals and has not known the secret of Lord-God 10.30. [%sig%]Admin · 03 Aug 2006
Thread Closed.