Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

some1 · 24 Jul 2006

What is it with these people. They claim that they are Sikhs or from a Sikh lineage. yet they don't understand that their brothern were slaughtered in PUnjab, their identity is under a constant attack (Sikh or in ur terms punjabi doe'snt matter, still brothern of the same mother). Their most sacred Shrine destroyed. Guru Granth Sahib under constant slander. Women raped, men burnt, kids destroyed, and familes left without families. WHY DO THESE PEOPLE NOT UNDERSTAND the concept of the RIGHT TO SELF-DETERMINATION?

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

J.A.T.T · 24 Jul 2006

They're brainwashed and/or uneducated about the movement. Also might have to do with how Indian media/government portray Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale Ji as a terrorist even though we all clearly know he wasn't one.

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

fresno sikh · 24 Jul 2006

ssakal Because most of them have Uncle Tom Negro Syndrome. Like as Malcom X movie says that when the master got sick the slave said "we sick". He (slave)thought his own identity was through his master who abused him, took his identity, name, culture and religion etc and made him feel worthless.

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

Dilbagh Puri · 24 Jul 2006

Fateh Ji, I think you live in a very small and narrow world. What do you mean self determination like khalistan. How many sikhs are there in Punjab. If you ask for self determination and call for election. At present there may be approximately 52 % sikhs and 48 % hindus Punjabi speaking. They will not be in favor of khalistan. Out of 52 % sikhs ther are many do not fall in line with your ideology. I mean to say radhaswomi, namdhari and many other sant samajs they also do not like khalistan ideology. So Merely 30 percents may come out in favor of khalistan. So if you could get khalistan after self determination election comducted by UN, finall khalistan will consist of 3 or 4 districts of Punjab. Then there will be repatriation from all over india like was there in 1947. Many will be killed After 1947 we lost half of sikh historical gurudwars and now you see what is the condition of Gurudwaras in Pakistan. After another partition other half of gurudwaras will left in India. We may loose two or three takhts after another partition. We may need visa to travel to Visit our historical guruwaras in India. So please do not dream such bad dream which is hamful for sikhism. We all may be talking about khalistan. Just have look in your family itself. 70% of sikhs are patits and may be 90% be additicted to Cocaine Tambaku and wines. Are these the constituents of khalistan So first of all let your family be image of khalistan. Your complete family be following tat gurmat rehit maryada. Then I can assure you, you need not struggle for khalistan. Khalistan will be automatically formed. Bhoo Chook muaf

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

some1 · 24 Jul 2006

mr. Puri, The fact that the Sikh number in the Punjab has declined is a direct attack on the Sikh identity and Punjabiyat. The government for years is trying to reduce the Sikh numbers in Punjab so that incase of refferendum the sikh vote will be diluted. your hypothesis is now rubbish.

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

some1 · 24 Jul 2006

As per your other complains. Sikhs can manage to associate with the Vichraye hoye Gurdwaras. Its been done in the past. Drugs, is a big reason Khalistan neesd to be made...all these "patits' need rehab. I'm sorry but you have given a clear cause for creating Khalistan.

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

Dilbagh Puri · 24 Jul 2006

Fateh, I response to "some1 " in the last post at 16:00 hrs on 24th July 2006, He is planning to have a stick in hand and herd the people to gurudwara for prayer and amrit chak and compel them to be not patit. Like Taliban tried in afghanistan to herd the people to masjid for five prayers. This type of rule cannot be stay long. People will surely throw them out. haaaaaah Bhool Chook Muaf

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

confused · 24 Jul 2006

then lets just say all of india should be ours cuz really its true and it was

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

fresno sikh · 24 Jul 2006

SSAKAL Khalistan will be made it is only matter of time. I was reading santokh singh gur partap suraj teeka. At one place it said there is fauj of saheed singh's are on the earth by thousands. It can only be seen by people kamai wale gursikhs. One such sikh travelling through a forest to see the Guru came across a saheed singh who said there are thousands of us on the earth in different places and five saheed singh are around where Guru ji sleep. On that to dispell his doubt he enlarged his body to miles and his height touched the sky. Shaeed were also around sant Harnam singh ji Rampur khera wale. He himself said that in his autobiography. Shaeed singh's were around sant Attar singh Mastuane wale people saw a Nahing singh like figure on a horse around his place where he slept and countless other examples. Sikhi tree roots are extremely deep all the way to patal as said by sant Attar Singh ji on answer to some sikhs who converted to Arya Samaj. "Raj Karega Khalsa"

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

PTE SINGH · 25 Jul 2006

Or perhaps many people just do not agree with your point of view Gents. Why do you seem to think that those that do not agree with the idea of Khalistan and disagree with the actions of Bhindrawalla are in some way uneducated, brainwashed or less Sikh. Most Sikhs do not have a black and white opinion on the matter, as the mess that occured in 1980's Punjab was not a black and white issue. The attack on the Harminder Shaib was a disgraceful operation and the Delhi riots were amongest the worst cases of human rights violations of the time, but that does not automatically make Bhindrawalla right or create a viable reason for Khalistan. [%sig%]

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

Singh · 25 Jul 2006

Well said PTE SINGH.....I live in the Midlands (Derby). The town has a very pro-Khalistani Gurdwara. One cannot have a balanced conversation with some of the guys that attend the pro-Khalistani Gurdwara. Any hint of anti-Bhindrawala dissent and they are ready to decapitate you. Gurfeteh Ji and thank you for clarifying that the issue in the 1980s was not black and white. PS: My parents were in india at the time....they almost lost their lives on a train that was attacked by fascist Hindu mobs. They saw the descecrated Akal Takht. This brought tears to their eyes and wounded them psychologically. However.....when they spoke to some of the Delhi residents (we have relatives in Delhi) who had lost their nearest and dearest in the riots....the relatives actually blamed Bindrawala for the violent death of their loved ones. So who is right and who is wrong....? Gurfateh Ji [%sig%]

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

Mehtab Singh · 25 Jul 2006

Sikhi is the future of not just India but the whole world. No other qaum ([i]as far as I know[/i]) has slogans like Raj Karega Khalsa that GurSikhs have. Gurujee said it for a purpose. [%sig%]

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

PTE SINGH · 25 Jul 2006

To Singh My apologies regarding the state of Derby Gurdwara, as it was my fellow Gravesendians, including my cousins, father and uncles amongst others that instigated the Khalistani coupe there in the mid eighties. I was far to young back then other wise i am sure i would have been in the thick of the battle that ensued. However even staunch Khalistanis and pro Bhindrawalla supporters like many members of my family now do accept the validity of others views on the subject . Hopefully Derby and other hotbeds of the Khalistan movement will at some point accept that people’s views change with time and that others are allowed to have a differing opinion.

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

some1 · 25 Jul 2006

the mobs consisted of 100% hindu, therefore hindu mobs. Simple uneducated and cold hearted are the only ones against.

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

sum1else · 25 Jul 2006

dear pte singh, and singh wat do u mean by the "actions of bhindranwale" which "actions" are u talking about?

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

PTE SINGH · 26 Jul 2006

Sumelese The actions i am refering to are Bhindrawallas armed occupation of Gurdwara buildings without authority and the fortification of said sacred buildings. As well the refusal to fight outside the Harminder Shaib complex and thus using the people inside and the sacred shrines as shields.

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

some1 · 26 Jul 2006

I did not say i hate hindus, but the mobs were hindu mobs. PTE SINGH, read ne book, 37 other Gurdwaras were attacked, it wuz irrespective where Sant ji was. He did his duty of defending Siri Hariminder Sahib from the likes of the Ghandi regime.

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

Sidharth · 26 Jul 2006

Author: some1 Date: 07-25-06 19:41 the mobs consisted of 100% hindu, therefore hindu mobs. Simple uneducated and cold hearted are the only ones against. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ totally incorrect. there were hundreds of muslims that participated in the riots as well and don't forget that Jagdish Tytler and Oscar Fernandes are both Christians: I. POLITICIANS The following is the list of those alleged to have instigated violence and/or protected alleged criminals. 1. Mr. H.K.L. Bhagat, Minister of state (Information and Broadcasting). On November 5, reported to have intervened to get miscreants released who were held in Shahdara Thana. 2. Babu Ram Sharma, Member, Municipal Corporation (Ward No. 58) reported to be the right-hand man of H. K. L. Bhagat. Reportedly responsible for loot, arson and murder in trance-Yamuna areas-Babarpur, Chajupur Colony, Maujpur, Gonda. Allegedly led people on motor cycle with megaphone. 3. Sajjan Kumar, Cong. (I) M.P. from Mangolpuri. Reported to have paid Rs. 100 and a bottle of liquor to each person involved in the killing. 4. Lalit Makan, Cong. (I) Trade Union Leader and Metropolitan Councillor. Reportedly paid to mob Rs. 100 each plus a bottle of liquor. A white ambassador car reportedly belonging to him came 4 times to the G.T. Road area near Azadpur. Instructions to mobs indulging in arson were given from inside the car. 5. Dharam Das Shastri, Cong. (I) M. P. from Karol Bagh. Reported to becarrying voters list with him at Prakash Nagar for identification of Sikhs. On November 5, according to newspaper reports, he along with other Congress-I leaders tried to pressurize the SHO of Karol Bagh Police Station to release the persons who arrested during the police raids to recover looted property. 6. Jagdish Tytler, Cong.(I) M. P. from Sadar Constitutency. On 6th November 5 p.m. he barged into a press conference that the Police Commissioner S. C. Tandon was holding. A journalist reports that he told the Police Commissioner that "by holding my men you are hampering the relief work". 7. Mahendra, Metropolitan Councillor. Reported to have accompanied Dharam Das Shastri with voters lists at Prakash Nagar. 8. Mangat Ram Singal, Member of Municipal Corporation (Ward No. 32) was reportedly with Dharam Das Shastri and Mahendra at Prakash Nagar. 9. Dr. Ashok Kumar, Member of Municipal Corporation, Kalyanpuri. Reportedly held a meeting in Kalyanpuri, following which violence broke out immediately. According to many eye witnesses he led mobs which indulged in loot, murder, arson and rape. 10. Sukhan Lal Sood, Metropolitan Councillor. According to eye witnesses was seen leading mobs, which indulged in loot, murder, arson and rape. He had come with petrol and serial lists and addressess of Sikhs in the locality. The women refugees, recognized him and drove him out. 11. Jagdish Chander Tokas, Member of Municipal Corporation Munirka (Ward No. 14) reportedly led a mob to R.K. Puram Sector IV and V. 12. Ishwar Singh, Member, Municipal Corporation, Mangolpuri (Ward No. 37). Allegedly led the mobs that indulged in looting, burning, rape and murder in Mangolpuri area. 13. Balwant Khokhar, Youth Congress-I Leader, Delhi, Identified as one of the persons responsible for instigating looting and arson in Palam Colony area. 14. Faiz Mohammad, Youth Congress-I Leader, Delhi, named by refugees in Shakurpur camp and in Mangolpuri for being a part of the mob indulging in looting, arson and murder. 15. Ratan, Youth Congress-I Leader, Delhi, named as having taken part in violence and looting in Palam Colony area. 16. Satbir Singh, Youth Congress-I. He allegedly brought bus loads of people from Ber Sarai to Sri Guru Harkrishan Public School (Munirka). They burnt school buses and parts of the school building. He was reportedly involved in looting and beating of Sikhs which carried on throughout the night on November 1. II. POLICE The following is the list of police officials allegedly responsible for negligence of duty and more abetment of /participation in violence : 1.Malhotra, ACP, East Districts at Shakarpur (under Shakarpur P. S.) Reported to have invited mobs. Heard to say "You should have blown up the Gurudwaras in addition to killing Bhatia (Congress-I worker, Trilochan Singh Bhatia ) of M. Block, Shakarpur. Mob was accompanied by Malhotra, who moved with one jeep, station-wagon, two men with sten-guns and revolvers, petrol-cans and stones. He supplied weapons to the mob, according to eve-witness accounts. Reportedly incited mobs at Laxmi Nagar, Gurunangal Nagar (under Shahdara P. S. ) 2. Jai Singh, S.H.O., Allegedly told mobs in troubled area that they could do what they wanted for three days. 3. Rao Ram Mehar, S.H.O. at Shakarpur reportedly pointed out Shik shops and houses to the mob. 4. Hari Ram Bhatti, S.H.O. Sultanpuri P. S. reported to have helped the mob by disarming the Sikhs. On November 1 and 2 it is alleged that he himself killed them. On 3 and 4 reported to have had the Sikhs shaven at gun point. 5. Ravtas Singh, S.H.O. Sadar Thana. Reportedly broke into houses and indulged in arson. 6. Survir Singh, S.H.O. Kalyanpuri, P. S. He reported reached Trilokpuri (under Kalyanpuri P. S.) at 2.30 p.m. On November 1, when plunder and killing were going on. He immediately removed head constable and another constable from the spot, thereby giving the mob full licence to indulge in arson, rape and killing. 7. R. D. Singh, S.I. Information from refugees at Durgapuri Gurudwara, Loni Road that he abetted mobs and personally beat up and killed people. 8. S.H.O. and Constables. R. K. Puram Sector IV P. S. According to eye witness account when appealed to by two residents of Ber Sarai to project a Sikh family being attacked by a mob in Sector IV they categorically refused. Furhter, they are reported to have declared that Sikhs should be killed. The following are the names of other police officials reported to have abetted / participated in violence in the mentioned areas : 9. Tyagi, S.H.O. in Trilokpuri. 10. Rana, Inspector-in-Trilokpuri. 11. Moolchand, S. I. In Shakarpur. 12. Bakshi, A.S.I. in Trilokpuri. 13. Rajvir Singh, Head Constable, Kalyanpuri, P. S. in Trilokpuri. III OTHERS INVOLVED The following is the list of persons allegedly involved in looting, arson and other criminal activities: TRILOKPURI: BLOCK -5 1. Papita, one of the ring leaders allegdly involved in murder. BLOCK-12 : 2. Brahmani (Misrani) Shastri. BLOCK-14 : 3. Baleshwar Bhargi alias Bhalu. 4. Bal Kishan BLOCK-21 : 5. Bihari Dhobi. BLOCK-25 6. B. D. Sharma. BLOCK-27 : 7. Israi Ali (alias Chunnu). 8. Salim, Well known goonda, allegedly involved in murder. 9. Massa, opium dealer. BLOCK-28 : 10. Dr. Yahya Siddiqi, Clinic at Main Road, Block -27, reportedly led the mob.\ 11. Manu Singh, shop-keeper. 12. Soni, Railway Worker. 13. Mukesh, reportedly involved in loot and murder. BLOCK-29 : 14. Mukri Master, Tailor, allegedly involved in murder. BLOCK-30 : 15. Om Prakash (Omi), Mason, allegedly involved in murder. 16. Ved Prakash (Brother if Om Prakash), Handpump Mistri, allegedly involved in murder and rape. 17.Nur Jahan, reported to have incited Muslims by spreading the rumours that mosques have been burnt by Sikhs. 18. Keramat, Dealer in Cement. 19. Shabnam, TV shop owner. 20. Damesh 21. Punju 22. Salim allegedly involved in murder. 23.Abbas Son-in-law (see Abbas in Block 32). 24. Mukri, Video shop owner. 25. Hasin. BLOCK-31 : 26. Kamaruddin, Atta-Chakki shop owner, and Furniture dealer. 27. Niyamat Ali. 28. Ninav, Tea shop owner. 29. Dr. V. P. Singh. 30. Duli Chand, Local Leader. BLOCK-32: 31. Rampal Saroj, Pradhan and Congress -I worker. Allegedly responsible for killing of Gopal Singh, Ranjha Singh, Mekal Singh. Other charges against him are instigation, rape and burning. 32. Kishori lal and his four brothers, Shrawan, Sbrlya, Chhote, Kamal, own a Meat shop. Allegedly responsible for killing of HuRum Singh, Tirath, Sajjan Singh, Soma Singh, Tara Singh. 33. Jagga Sansi and wife Draupadi, allegedly responsible for burning, murder and rape. 34. Khadak Singh Pradhan. 35. Gaffar Khan, Businessman dealing in Cement. 36. Babu Khan, owns a dairy. 37. Manu Sansi 38. Aasim. 39. Somnath, allegedly responsible for killing of several persons including Hoshiar Singh S/o Milap Singh and 3 young men whom he locked in the house and killed later with other people. 40. Ajit. 41. Kadir. 42. Monga. 43. Sati. 44. Tello Sansi (Draupadi's sister) 45. Ruplal, allegedly responsible for killing of Labh Singh, r/o 32/121. 46. Omi Chamar, Shoemaker. 47. Morari, owns grocery shop in Block-31. 48. Pahelwan (Brother of Rashid). 49. Bachchan. 50. Aziz. 51. Ansar. 52. Kallo Khan, Dhaba owner. 53. Abbas, owns cloth and chappal shop in Block-27. 54. Dr. Lambo. 55. Bhallo, Sells liquors. 56. Kayamat Ali. 57. Raju (Bhangi), Sweeper. 58. Jaggi. 59. Bhaya. 60. Murli Khan. 61. Sher Khan. 62. Raja Ram, Rickshaw Driver. 63. Bethis Ramesh. 64. Bedhu Ram, allegedly responsible for killing in 32/99 and 32/97. BLOCK -33: 65. Pappu, allegedly responsible for murder. 66. Bhum, local goonda. 67. Gyano, student. 68. Mohammad, Cycle shop owner. 69. Birju. 70. Zakir. 71. Kamal Singh, Rickshaw owner. 72. Munshi. 73. Rashid, Cycle Rickshaw repair shop in Block-32, allegedly involved in murder. BLOCK- 34: 74. Mahendru. 75. Ratan (brother of Mahendru). 76. Behem Sharma. 77. Mahendra Pal. 78. Sher Singh, Shop keeper. BLOCK- 35: 79. Jeevan. BLOCK- 36: 80. B. B. Pandoy. OTHER BLOCKS: 81. D. R. Lakhani, Youth Congress-I. 82. Abdulla. 83. Two sons of Sitaram, Milkman. 84. A.Mulla, lives near Mosque in Trilokpuri, teaches children in Mosque. Allegedly incited Muslims to go to burn two Gurudwaras of the locality. 85. Lakhan. 86. Rohtas, Land owner and Goala. 87. Rishi, Land owner and Goala. 88. Kripal, Land owner and Goala. 89. Brahrn (Tea shop owner in Trilokpuri). 90. Chabban & Munim, Cloth and Tailoring Shop near Mosque. Allegedly responsible for the death of Duleep Singh. 91. Babu Sharma. SULTANPURI: BLOCK- A- 4: 92. A. Bagri, Pradhan. 93. Brahmanand Gupta, Pradhan. 94. Nathu Pradhan, Sweeper. 95. Udal Jat. 96. Owner of Hanuman Ration shop. 97. Gayanand, Shop owner. 98. Ganpat, Shop owner. 99. Piria (Gujrati). 100. Gurbat Brothers. 101. Islam. 102. Rao. 103. Changa, Doctor. 104. Omi, auto-rickshaw driver. 105. Garib Das. 106. Vermanand, Kerosene seller. BLOCK A-5: 107. Hasla Ram. 108. Mangla. 109. Satbir. 110. Salam. BLOCK B-1: 111. Pal Brahman. 112. Samthu. 113. Khismvia. 114. Kumar. BLOCK- 3: 115. Gopal & Brothers 116. Babbar & Father 117. Tiwari 118. Raghubir,Sweeper 119.Pratap,Sweeper 120. Wajiz BLOCK- C- 4: 121. Barjilal & Sons. 122. Kalaram and 2 sons 123. Prem Singh alias Prem Muchiwal, Property dealer 124.Jai Kishan, Sweeper 125.Danny 126. Pappu 127. Raju 128. Ravikaran, Tailor 129. Kannaram. 130. Mohan Lal s/o Thekeda Komal BLOCK P-3: 131. Tara Chand, Carpenter. 132. Master, Kerosene seller 133. Radhe Shyam, Mechanie 134. Babu Lal, Vegetable seller 135. The brother of Sikandar 136. Gulab Singh, owner of Godown MONGOLPURl: 137. Hardwari Lal, Mandal President 138. Narendar Singh, Congress-I Worker 139. Salim Qureshi, Congress-I worker, belongs to Waqf Club 140. Shawkeen, Congress- I Worker, belong to Waqf Club 141. Malaram, Congress- I worker 142. Rajendar of New Star Club 143. Shiv Charan MAUJPUR: GONDA: 144. Bhisno Joginder, Kerosene seller 145. Trilok, Flour Mill owner 146. Gupta, Paper seller 147. Delu Ram, Tailor's Apprentice 148. Ram Kishan, Tailor's Apprentice 149. Bhola, MilLman I 150. Balbir, Milkman s son 151. Prem, Barber 152. Gyan Malwai 153. Narain's son 154. Brahm SHAKARPUR: 155. Bhatia, Congress - I Worker 156. Dogra, Congress-I worker 157. Mr. Singh, Congress-I worker 158. Lakshmi Dhoban, Mahila Samiti, allegedly instigated mobs to burns Sikhs alive. 159. Mr. Ashwini, BJP worker 160. Satpal, owner of 3-star hotel on main Shakarpur highway. 161. Ashok Kumar, owns a flour mill in Shakarpur. 162. Ram Niwas Sharma 163. Rohtas Singh, Shakarpur Village. KHAJURI KHAS: 164. Kadam Singh, Panchayat Sarpanch 165. Nephews of Kadam Singh 166. Nambat Singh, owns Ration shop in the area. 167. Shyam Lal, Retired ASI. 168. Jai Singh, Kerosene seller 169. Jugnu. 170. Parsa JANAKPURI: 171. Pratap, Pradhan of Sagarpur, allegedly responsible for killing 22 members of the family of Budh Singh of Sagarpur near Janakpuri. BLOCK C: 172. Dablu, Sweeper 173. Kalia, Sweeper 174. Upli, Sweeper 175. Son Sasi 176. Mohan Sasi 177. Bhana Sasi 178. Raju, Sweeper 179. Malaram, allegedly distributed free kerosene MANDAVALI: UNCHPUR 180. Sachdeva, property dealer 181. Raj Kalia, Cement dealer 182. Gupta, alias Chakki, owns Grocery store 183. Ram Prakash, works in Khadi Bhawan 184. Dr. Babbar 185. Dharam Pal 186. Kishan Dutt 187. Babu Ram 188.Lal Bahadur Mishra 189. Joshi RAJNAGAR: 190. Balwan Khokkar 191. Mohinder Singh Bargdola 192. Pandit Tara Chand 193. Ishwar Chand Verma 194. Pandit Ram Niwas SADAR BAZAAR: 195. Kamal, Dhobi 196. David, Dhobi's son 197. Vinayak Family AZADPUR INDUSTRIAL AREA: 198. T. S. Bedi, Factory owner. On Nov. 1 he is reported to have organized mobs from early morning which became active later. While his own factory was left untouched, the neighbouring Crown Motors factory belonging to Sardar Pyare Singh was gutted the same day. http://www.outlookindia.com/full.asp?fodname=20050808&fname=pudrpucl&sid=17&pn= And here is the proof that Jagdish Tytler is a Christian: "The Christians are Oscar Fernandes from Karnataka and Jagdish Tytler from Delhi — both from the Congress." http://www.sulekha.com/news/nhc.aspx?cid=335158 And who tried to save the Sikhs, the so called Brahmin RSS, Kushwant Singh a noted Hindu hater and critic of RSS himself admits this, here is some proof: "K.S.: R.S.S. is a communal organization and dangerous to the country's secular fabric. Look what they did to Muslims in Gujrat. However, they take a different approach with the Sikhs. During the 1984 Sikh pogrom, they did save many Sikh lives. R.S.S. volunteers participated during the tercentenary celebrations of the Khalsa in 1999. They consider the Khalsa to be a military wing of Hinduism and their savior." http://home.istar.ca/~cye/k%20singh%20-interview.html "It must be acknowledged that some leaders of the Sangh parivar and the RSS, including A.B.Vajpayee, went out of their way to help the Sikhs." http://www.outlookindia.com/full.asp?fodname=20050822&fname=Column+Khush+%28F%29&sid=1

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

Dilbagh Puri · 26 Jul 2006

Dear some1, fateh, You must go to the root cause of of the 1984 riots, wether they were hindus, congress person or BJP. Root cause was the prevailing atmosphere for the last 5 years. Dharm Yudh Morcha turned wrong direction and became violent. Kharkoos (you may say (jujharoos)started killing hindus in all over punjab. Explosions at hindu place of worship. Killing hindu bus passangers. This created a feeling rest of Indians that sikhs are criminals and anti nationalists. This atmosphere was fumed by killing by of Indira gandhi by her own body guards whom she trusted the most. The sikhs distributed sweets in Delhi, Punjab and India ather murder of Indira Gandhi. By this general public started hating sikhs as a whole and congress party cashed the snetiments of public and led the mobs to commit the attrocities againts sikhs. I can say that hindus as a whole are peace loving comunity. You see after that sikh community woke up and realized the situation that khalistan movement has turned to be voilent and khalistan dream cannot be realized through voilence Then sikhs as a whole departed away from khalistan movement. Finally khalistani movement died. Keeping the prevailing condition all over the world public sentiments are going against muslims. If this islamic terrorism keep on increasing like this, I think may be in coming next 5 to 20 years there will roits and muslims will be killed by public. There will be some group which may moblize the general public against muslims. Bhool Chook Muaf

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

sum1else · 26 Jul 2006

what "armed occupation of Gurdwara buildings"? Aren't sikhs supposed to carry weapons with them? correct me if im wrong.

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

unreal · 26 Jul 2006

Mr. Puri, While I have no problem with dissenting/differing views on the matter, your synopsis of the events is inaccurate at best and deliberately skewed at worst - I will give you the benefit of the doubt that perhaps you were careless in your recounting of the facts. So what is my gripe with your summary? Your summary implies, Sikhs attacked Hindus (your words: "killing hindus in all over punjab..explosions at hindu place of worship....killing hindu bus passengers...") AND THEN, general public started hating Sikhs, which eventually led to gov't sponsored genocidal attacks on the Sikhs in Delhi. Even though you state the attacks on the Sikhs were attrocities, your summary JUSTIFIES the attacks by indicating the Sikhs were the initiators and the attack was the eventual retaliation. This is grossly inaccurate. For the sake of your integrity, I hope you did not mean to imply this and that you simply were careless in your post. The fact of it is, there was long-standing un-happiness in Punjab with the way it was being treated by the central gov't, and this un-happiness/dissatisfaction existed without their being any documented attacks on Hindus or Hindu places of worship. The fact of it is, Indira Gandhi was killed after her order to assault Harmandir Sahib and countless other gurudwaras - keep in mind, the attack was ordered to take place on one of the busiest religious days for the Sikhs - the intent of Indira and cohorts was to desecrate, humilate, abuse, and kill to a maximum potential. Furthermore, you'll be hard pressed to find any legitimate charges against Sikhs re bombings of hindu places of worship, of hindus being killed en masse in Punjab etc. Of course, you'll find plenty of charges against Sikhs who were killed in "encounters" but if you believe those charges are legitimate, then you really do need to open your eyes... regards, unreal Dilbagh Puri wrote: > Dear some1, > > fateh, > You must go to the root cause of of the 1984 riots, > wether they were hindus, congress person or BJP. > Root cause was the prevailing atmosphere for the last 5 years. > Dharm Yudh Morcha turned wrong direction and became violent. > Kharkoos (you may say (jujharoos)started killing hindus in all > over punjab. Explosions at hindu place of worship. Killing > hindu bus passangers. This created a feeling rest of Indians > that sikhs are criminals and anti nationalists. This atmosphere > was fumed by killing by of Indira gandhi by her own body guards > whom she trusted the most. The sikhs distributed sweets in > Delhi, Punjab and India ather murder of Indira Gandhi. By this > general public started hating sikhs as a whole and congress > party cashed the snetiments of public and led the mobs to > commit the attrocities againts sikhs. I can say that hindus as > a whole are peace loving comunity. > > You see after that sikh community woke up and realized the > situation that khalistan movement has turned to be voilent and > khalistan dream cannot be realized through voilence Then sikhs > as a whole departed away from khalistan movement. Finally > khalistani movement died. > > Keeping the prevailing condition all over the world public > sentiments are going against muslims. If this islamic terrorism > keep on increasing like this, I think may be in coming next 5 > to 20 years there will roits and muslims will be killed by > public. There will be some group which may moblize the general > public against muslims. > Bhool Chook Muaf [%sig%]

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

Singh · 26 Jul 2006

Couple of Interesting points.. Kirpal Singh, President of Khalsa Dewan, Amritsar If the government had been sincere in its efforts in solving the Punjab problem, it would have solved it long ago even before the Blue Star Operation, and there would have been no cause for the Akalis and others to orgainise Morchas of the thousands of the peopl, from time to time, and the extremists would have been isolated and it would have become known as to who were the extremists, what kind of men they were, and what they had been doing. The Government could have negotiated with them. If the Government could talk with Laldenga of Mizos and extremists of the Nagaland, who had been fighting with our military for the last 31 years, then what was the difficulty in talking to the extemi sts of Punjab and asking them what they wanted, what they were fighting and why they were collecting arms?" S.S. Bhagowalia who is the Vice-President of the Association fro Protection of Democratic Rights (Punjab) when the government in 1948 could control and capture Hyderbad from the Nizam who wanted to secede from independent India without any violence and killing of the common people, why this Government could not capture Bhindranwale with tact, without any damage to the Golden Temple? This has created tension and anger amongst the minds fo the people" Surinder Singh Rag "The Indian Army had captued 93,000 soldiers of Pakistan army in Bangladesh in 1971 without bloodshed. Was bloodshed the absolutely necessary at the Golden Temple to flush out a hundred or so terrorists?" Main reason for Operation Blue Star Operation blue star was not an Operation against Bhindranwale and other so called terrorists according to the Government, it was an attack on the Sikhs "to teach them a lesson" so that they would never again raise their head or voice of protest. We all know that it was 99.9% hindus attacking the sikhs during the mobs.. u cant deny this chandra no matter wat ur excuse is.. u can say all the crap u want but u no that u and ur rss buddies jus wanted to see sikhs dead.

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

PTE SINGH · 27 Jul 2006

Sumlese Are you being purposely awkward or are you truly that naïve? There is a difference between carrying personal weapons, that every Sikh has the right to in India, and fortifying positions with sand bags, LMG’s, firing posts, sniper rifles and RPG. But I’m sure that the next Sikh person arrested in England for carrying a grenade launcher may try your logic as a defence. Correct me if I’m wrong but most governments only allow their military that kind of arsenal. Some1 I am well aware of the other Gurdwara where operations were carried out, that would be the standard procedure after an operation that went as wrong as BLUE STAR. Those Gurdwara were not chosen at random but were those on which intelligence was received about armed Bhindrawalla supporters being present. On some of them the Intel was good on some it was wrong, that’s what happens when militant wings are allowed into shrines. [%sig%]

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

Dilbagh Puri · 27 Jul 2006

Fateh Ji, It is long story and every one know that sikhs had been struggling to get their due share in India. But I am sure Akalis had done more harm to sikhism than congress as a whole. If Chief minister Karoian like people had been their. punjab would have been min Europe of India. But Akalis they are the most corrupt party in India. They cannot do good for sikhism and punjab as whole. Fateh

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

Dilbagh Puri · 28 Jul 2006

fateh Ji, In response to Mr unreal post. Author is telling to give me the benefit of doubt and says it as a careless post. I want to ask him at the time of roits was he in india or in Canada and if In India was he in Punjab or other parts of India. I think he was in punjab only. Had he been in out of Punjab, he should not have considered my post as unreal and careless. You see after reading my first post many post came out saying they want whole India as khalistan. If you are minority have raproachment with your surroundings and have a cordial atmosphere with your neighbours. Some where in the post I find people saying that had the government accepted the akalis demands at that time. Then there would not have been this blood shed. You can find from the demands that if akalis come to centre they would not have accepted those demands. It is a politics nothing else. Only way to realize khalistan is to make your family an image of khalistan. So please start taking correective measures in your own family first. fateh

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

some1 · 28 Jul 2006

Very clearly this post shows that some "sikhs" or people who are from sikh families aer against Khalistan, without having a proper education, or knowing that facts and just loving bloodywood. my dad always says "kaum daye jarda vich pani pya hoya"

Re: Anti-Khalistan, pro India.

Guru Ghar Da Kookar · 28 Jul 2006

Pyre Veer Fresno Sikh, Guru Fateh......... A very nice dream and I can say keep dreaming ........this dream.......Don't which Gurbani u read and if u read I think u never go through the message inside that.........One thing I can say for u buddy ur LIVING IN A FOOL'S PARADISE.........Keep waiting for ur so callled Shaheed Fauj ..........u will surely get one day........................